www.aclu.orgJOIN THE ACLUTAKE ACTIONABOUT US
ACLU Blog of Rights - Official Blog of the ACLU National Office American Civil Liberties Union Homepage Blog of Rights Homepage Support the ACLU
Jun 24th, 2008
Posted by James Freedland, ACLU at 6:47pm

Fight Censorship at the Border

Tomorrow in a Boston federal court, Melissa Goodman of the ACLU National Security Project will be challenging the federal government’s refusal to grant a visa to respected South African scholar Adam Habib. Back in the fall, the State Department denied Habib a visa after months of inaction, claiming that he is banned because he has “engaged in terrorist activities,” but the government failed to explain the basis for its inflammatory accusation, let alone provide even a shred of evidence to prove it.

We do know, however, that Habib – a distinguished professor and popular pundit in his home country – has openly objected to the war in Iraq and other U.S. foreign policies. And we have reason to believe that the government is excluding him based on ideological grounds.

By refusing to give Professor Habib a visa, the government is violating the constitutional speech rights of American citizens and residents. How, you ask? Because the right to hear speech is protected by the First Amendment too. Stifling the political debate in this country, the government’s refusal to grant visas to critics of this administration, like Habib and Tariq Ramadan, amounts to nothing less than censorship at the border.

That is why the ACLU filed this lawsuit last year on behalf of organizations that have invited Professor Habib to speak in the U.S. Sherif Fam of one of these groups, the Boston Coalition for Palestinian Rights, blogged today about why his organization joined our lawsuit:

Presenting no legitimate reason to deny Dr. Habib an entry visa, the State Department clearly intends to deny the American public access to views which may not conform exactly to the Administration's views. Besides violating the rights granted by our Constitution, what does that say about our country when we cannot tolerate differences of opinion?
Good question! We’ll keep fighting for every American’s right to enjoy the vigorous protection of speech that is guaranteed by the Constitution.

A Blog of Rights Service Announcement: We are currently implementing some exciting new changes to this website. While we work on this, blog comments have been disabled. But they'll be back up ASAP, so hold that thought and you'll be able to submit your comment soon.

3 Responses to "Fight Censorship at the Border"

  1. Ritchie Says:

    You people have lost your minds.

  2. Ryan Says:

    The United States Government is tasked with the responsibility of granting visas to those they deem appropriate to enter the country. I do not believe that a visa application equate to a right-to-entry. And, if the people have a Constitutional right to hear speech that is fine. The government still has no requirement to allow him in. It is the right of every American, then, to apply for a visa to South Africa and hear their hearts out. Nation-states exist for their people, exclusively. Where did we get into the business of granting rights to those on the outside?

  3. AlteredStates Says:

    I don't understand the fuss being made about hearing, and seeing someone speak in this country. We have the Internet, TV networks like CNN, Al Jezeera, Skynet, etc., that will give anyone with a valid message to be heard; and, the above media allows far greater exposure to one's thoughts than an auditorium would offer no matter how large.

    It may their ego that needs to be satisfied, and not their need to travel to the U.S. to be heard. The old ways of doing things has changed, in many ways, so why not change this outdated need to be seen. It isn't that important. The message is important, not the personality.

Comment

 

© ACLU, 125 Broad Street, 18th Floor New York, NY 10004
This is the Web site of the American Civil Liberties Union and the ACLU Foundation.
Learn more about the distinction between these two components of the ACLU.

User Agreement | Privacy Statement | FAQs | Site Map

Statistics image