www.aclu.orgJOIN THE ACLUTAKE ACTIONDONATEABOUT US
ACLU Blog of Rights - Official Blog of the ACLU National Office Blog of Rights Homepage Support the ACLU

Join Us At:

Aug 21st, 2009 Google Bookmarks Technorati StumbleUpon Digg! Reddit Delicious Facebook
Posted by Christopher Hill, Capital Punishment Project at 2:43pm

Supreme Court Orders Federal Court to Look at Evidence in Davis Case

The Supreme Court of the United States has ordered a federal district court judge (PDF) to "receive testimony and make findings of fact as to whether evidence that could not have been obtained at the time of trial clearly establishes [Davis's] innocence." A grant of an original writ of habeas corpus has not been granted by the court in 50 years. This order essentially gives Davis the evidentiary hearing for which he had been asking.

Justices Scalia and Thomas dissented. (PDF)

Tags: Troy Davis

May 20th, 2009 Google Bookmarks Technorati StumbleUpon Digg! Reddit Delicious Facebook
Posted by Suzanne Ito, ACLU at 5:29pm

Two Death Row Exonerations in Less Than 10 Days. Could Troy Davis Be Next?

Last week saw the exoneration of the 132nd person from death row since 1973. Paul House, who was on death row for 22 years and was scheduled for a new hearing, was exonerated after a DNA test proved he was not the perpetrator of the murder he was convicted of in 1986. Daniel Wade Moore became the 133rd exoneree when he was acquitted at a retrial for a 1999 rape and murder. Given the vast amount of people released from death row in the last 35 years, it is clear that capital punishment in the United States is fatally flawed and there is the unconscionable possibility to execute an innocent person. Troy Davis, who is almost certainly innocent, should have a chance to make the list of the exonerated. Instead, no court has heard evidence of his innocence.

Yesterday, Amnesty International organized a Global Day of Action for Troy Davis, who has been on Georgia's death row since 1989. The facts of Davis's case indicate that he is almost certainly innocent: Convicted and sentenced to death for the 1989 murder of Officer Mark MacPhail, an off-duty police officer, Davis's case lacks any physical evidence, and no murder weapon has been found. The only evidence against Davis is the testimony of witnesses. But seven of the nine nonpolice witnesses have recanted or contradicted their trial testimony. Of the two witnesses who did not recant, one is an alternative suspect.

Act now. Write Georgia Gov. Sonny Perdue and ask him to commute Troy Davis's sentence.

CORRECTION: An earlier version of this post stated the crimes for which Moore was convicted of took place in 2003. That was incorrect. They took place in 1999.

Tags: Troy Davis

May 15th, 2009 Google Bookmarks Technorati StumbleUpon Digg! Reddit Delicious Facebook
Posted by Christopher Hill, Capital Punishment Project at 5:55pm

Troy Davis Day of Action Next Tuesday

On May 19, 2009, there will be a Global Day of Action for Troy Davis sponsored by Amnesty International.

As you may recall, Davis awaits execution in Georgia for a crime of which he is almost certainly innocent. Davis was convicted and sentenced to death for the 1989 murder of Officer Mark MacPhail, an off-duty police officer. There is no physical evidence and no murder weapon has been found. The only evidence against Davis is the testimony of witnesses. Seven of the nine nonpolice witnesses have recanted or contradicted their trial testimony. Of the two witnesses that did not recant, oneis an alternative suspect.

Davis has come close to being executed several times even though evidence of his innocence has never received a hearing in court. If you are interested in attending a Global Day of Action event or would like more information, please visit Amnesty's Troy Davis Day of Action page.

Tags: Troy Davis

Apr 20th, 2009 Google Bookmarks Technorati StumbleUpon Digg! Reddit Delicious Facebook
Posted by Christopher Hill, Capital Punishment Project at 1:18pm

Troy Davis Suffers Another Blow

Late last week, the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals rejected Troy Davis’s petition for a hearing to prove his innocence. Although seven of the nine non-police witnesses against him have recanted or contradicted their trial testimony, that evidence will not be heard unless the United States Supreme Court decides differently. Troy Davis still has a 30-day stay of execution to file a petition with the Supreme Court.

The 11th Circuit refused to hear Davis’ claims of innocence by a 2-1 vote. The decision was largely based on the onerous procedural obstacles that a death row inmate must overcome before a federal court will consider the merits of his or her constitutional claims – in Troy’s case, his claim that the execution of an innocent person violates the cruel or unusual punishment clause of the U.S. Constitution.

These procedural restrictions are the result of the federal Anti-Terrorism and Effective Death Penalty Act (AEDPA), enacted in 1996. AEDPA was designed to expedite the execution of death-row inmates by streamlining the appeals process. But the Troy Davis case is a tragic illustration of AEDPA’s fundamental flaws. The law elevates procedural niceties over fairness and justice by preventing some death-row inmates from proving their innocence because their evidence or claim of innocence was presented too late.

The dissenting judge in Troy’s case stated, “[t]o execute Davis, in the face of a significant amount of proffered evidence that may establish his actual innocence, is unconscionable and unconstitutional.” We agree.

While Davis’s lawyers are working their way to the U.S. Supreme Court, you can still take action by voicing your opposition to horrific injustice. Visit Amnesty International’s website for an update of actions you can take.

Tags: Troy Davis

Feb 4th, 2009 Google Bookmarks Technorati StumbleUpon Digg! Reddit Delicious Facebook
Posted by Suzanne Ito, ACLU at 3:29pm

Troy Davis Video and Update

Amnesty International teamed up with rock band State Radio to create a music video based on the case of Troy Davis. Check it out:

Please note that by playing this clip You Tube and Google will place a long-term cookie on your computer. Please see You Tube's privacy statement on their website and Google's privacy statement on theirs to learn more. To view the ACLU's privacy statement, click here.

Troy Davis had a hearing before the 11th Circuit in December; we're now awaiting a decision on whether the court will grant an evidentiary hearing under the Antiterrorism and Effective Death Penalty Act (AEDPA). That hearing would then determine whether he gets a new trial in which he could bring his innocence claims.

If he isn't granted a new hearing under AEDPA, there is a possibility that the State of Georgia could still proceed with execution. So it's crucial that you head over to Amnesty's petition to Georgia Governor Sonny Perdue, and ask him to influence the state's board of parole and pardons to grant clemency to Troy Davis. (In Georgia, the governor doesn't have the power to pardon himself, but Perdue appointed many of the officials sitting on the board, and can suggest to the board that the sentence be commuted.)

And keep in mind, these petitions work! Sue Gunawardena-Vaughn, Director of Amnesty’s Death Penalty Abolition Campaign, says: "The volume of demonstrations/petitions has been crucial in raising the profile of this case with both the media and with public officials. If there hadn't been public outrage over this case, Troy would probably have been executed when the very first execution date was set back in July 2007."

So act now to save Troy Davis's life. There is still work to be done.

Tags: Troy Davis

Dec 1st, 2008 Google Bookmarks Technorati StumbleUpon Digg! Reddit Delicious Facebook
Posted by Jack Payden-Travers, Capital Punishment Project at 6:19pm

Oral Arguments in Troy Davis Case

A date has been set for the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals to hear oral arguments in Troy Davis's case. The 11th Circuit, which ordered a stay of execution on October 24,will hear arguments on December 9, 2008.

The issue before the court is whether Mr. Davis can meet the standards for an evidentiary hearing under the 1996 Antiterrorism and Effective Death Penalty Act (AEDPA). Davis must show that he possesses new clear and convincing evidence that could not have been discovered previously and which no reasonable fact-finder would have found him guilty.

In addition, the three-judge panel of the 11th Circuit has requested that both sides address the issue of whether Mr. Davis can be executed if he fails to meet the procedural hurdles under AEDPA but can establish his actual innocence. Seven out of nine eyewitnesses have either recanted or changed their trial testimony. The Fulton County Daily Report has written an article entitled "11th Circuit Raises Big Questions by Delving Into Death Row Case."

While attorneys for each side will argue the fine points of law on December 9, letters to the editor about this case are an excellent way to express your concern about our dysfunctional death penalty system where one can be procedurally barred from presenting claims of actual innocence.

Tags: Troy Davis

Oct 24th, 2008 Google Bookmarks Technorati StumbleUpon Digg! Reddit Delicious Facebook
Posted by Suzanne Ito, ACLU at 1:57pm

Troy Davis Execution Stayed!

The 11th Circuit Court of Appeals has agreed to give Troy Davis time to show why he is entitled to a new appeal to pursue his innocence claims. The AJC has more.

Tags: Troy Davis

Oct 23rd, 2008 Google Bookmarks Technorati StumbleUpon Digg! Reddit Delicious Facebook
Posted by Suzanne Ito, ACLU at 1:20pm

Attorneys for Troy Davis Continue to Work to Save His Life; D.C. Rally Info

The AJC reports today that Troy Davis' attorneys are seeking permission from the a federal appeals court to file a new round of appeals based on Troy's innocence claims. If the 11th Circuit grants the request, Troy's Monday execution will be stayed. The paper reports:

Davis' court filing said the Antiterrorism and Effective Death Penalty Act of 1996 allows a condemned inmate to seek a second round of federal appealsif a federal appeals court approves it. Davis' lawyers told the 11th Circuitthey have made the requisite showing of actual innocence to allow a newround of appeals to begin.
You can join Amnesty's Global Day of Action (PDF) today. Let's continue to show that the public won't stand for the execution of a man whose guilt is questioned. A third rally in Washington, D.C., will be from 6 p.m. to 7 p.m. at the corner of 14th St. and Park Rd. NW, in the paved triangular area right by the Columbia Heights metro station.

Tags: Troy Davis

Oct 23rd, 2008 Google Bookmarks Technorati StumbleUpon Digg! Reddit Delicious Facebook
Posted by Suzanne Ito, ACLU at 10:17am

Take a Stand for Troy Davis Today in NYC and Atlanta

Now that the Supreme Court has refused to hear Troy Davis's case, all we can do is hope that a public outcry against his October 27 execution will hit a nerve with Georgia's Board of Pardons and Paroles, which can commute his sentence to life in prison.

Amnesty International is organizing a global day of action for Troy Davis today. A rally on Georgia's state capitol steps (206 Washington St. SW) will include speakers Larry Cox of Amnesty and Steve Hawkins of the NAACP, and will be MC'd by Lorraine Jacques White, radio host on WAOK. Call (404) 876-5661 x13 for more information.

A second rally will be held in front of Penn Station (33rd St. at Eighth Ave.) in New York City from 5:30 p.m. to 6:30 p.m. Please join Amnesty and the ACLU in calling for justice for Troy Davis. Troy is almost certainly innocent. Make your voice heard that you won't stand for the execution of a man when serious doubt about his guilt remains.

The first 20 people to show for the New York rally will receive a free "I Am Troy Davis" T-shirt, so get there early, and bring a friend (or 10)!

CORRECTION: An earlier version of this post stated that Al Sharpton would be speaking at the Atlanta rally. Sharpton will no longer be speaking at that event.

Tags: Troy Davis

Oct 6th, 2008 Google Bookmarks Technorati StumbleUpon Digg! Reddit Delicious Facebook
Posted by John Holdridge, Director, Capital Punishment Project at 12:50pm

Troy Davis Case Proves Death Penalty Is Fatally Flawed

The U.S. death penalty system is a failed government program unworthy of a people that cherish fairness and justice. If we needed any further proof of this fact, the Troy Davis case seals the deal.

On September 23, 2008, Troy Davis came within two hours of being executed. He was at least temporarily saved when the United States Supreme Court granted a last-minute stay to give it time to decide whether to review his case. But Troy is not out of the woods. If the Supreme Court decides not to take his case, he will once again face execution.

Troy Davis has steadfastly maintained his innocence for all of the many years he has been imprisoned on Georgia's death row. An African-American, Davis was convicted of the murder of a white, off-duty Savannah Police Officer named Mark MacPhail in 1991. Not a shred of physical evidence links him to the crime. No murder weapon has been found. Nine non-police witnesses testified against him at trial, but all but two of these witnesses have either recanted their testimony or gave contradictory statements prior to Troy's trial. Some of the recanting witnesses now assert that they were coerced by police to say that Davis was the murderer. One of the witnesses who did not recant was seen acting suspiciously the night of Officer MacPhail's murder and has been heard boasting that he killed an off-duty police officer.

As extraordinary as it seems, despite the collapse of the case against Troy Davis, and despite the pleas on Troy's behalf by such leading figures of moral authority as Pope Benedict XVI, former president Jimmy Carter and Nobel Peace Prize-winner Desmond Tutu (PDF), the State of Georgia still wants to execute him.

This deeply troubling case illustrates four truths about our capital punishment system.

First, it is fraught with error. In the past 35 years, 130 innocent death row inmates have been exonerated and released after years on death row, and eight men have been executed even though there were serious questions about their guilt. In other words, the system can't reliably determine who is guilty, let alone who deserves the death penalty. And, despite popular myths, DNA is no panacea to the scourge of wrongful convictions and executions. It is available in only 10 percent of all murder cases.

That's Troy Davis' biggest problem. He cannot convince some death penalty supporters that he is innocent because there is no DNA evidence available to conclusively exclude him as the culprit. These supporters of capital punishment defend his conviction and death sentence by citing the flimsy evidence presented at his trial. But then they turn around and demand that Troy Davis prove his innocence with unassailable, irrefutable evidence.

That's not how our capital punishment system should work. When it comes to the death penalty, innocence should never have to be proven beyond a shadow of a doubt. We must not execute a human being if there is any legitimate chance that he is innocent.

Second, our judicial system can no longer monitor and control the use of capital punishment. Courts and legislators have made it so difficult for death-row inmates to challenge their convictions and death sentences that the system is unable to correct its own mistakes. It has become like an 18-wheeler barreling down a mountain, with no run-off lanes to stop it.

Third, the death penalty is infected by economic discrimination. It's a poor man's penalty. It is about poor people receiving death sentences because their lawyers were too overworked and underfunded to properly represent them.

Some politicians love to go around proclaiming their support for capital punishment but then they turn around and refuse to pay for a fair system. Capital defenders are given grossly inadequate time and resources to adequately defend their clients. We are seeing that again today with the funding crisis in Georgia's system of providing lawyers for poor people. Fourth, the death penalty discriminates on the basis of race. Study after study in state after state, including Georgia, has demonstrated that, everything else being equal, a defendant is about three to four times more likely to get a death sentence if he kills a white person than if he kills a person of color. And the combination most likely to get the death penalty is a black defendant convicted of killing a white victim.

As former Supreme Court Justice Harry Blackmun declared: “race continues to play a major role in determining who shall live and who shall die.”

In short, the Troy Davis case is a no brainer. The State of Georgia must not execute him. After all, as Justice Blackmun also once said, the execution of an innocent man comes perilously close to murder.

Tags: Troy Davis

  • 1
  • 2
  • Next Page
 

Quicksearch


© ACLU, 125 Broad Street, 18th Floor New York, NY 10004
This is the Web site of the American Civil Liberties Union and the ACLU Foundation.
Learn more about the distinction between these two components of the ACLU.

User Agreement | Privacy Statement | FAQs | Site Map