American Civil Liberties Union

The LGBT Project fights discrimination and moves public opinion on LGBT rights through the courts, legislatures and public education. >> More About the Project


Tell 3 Contact Us

Ideological Exclusion

ACLU NewsfeedsACLU News Feed
ACLU Blog
US Constitution

In re: Gill

A challenge to Florida's ban on adoption by gay parents.

Martin Gill and his partner of more than eight years have been raising two foster children of the state since 2004. When they arrived, the infant and his four-year-old brother had clearly suffered from neglect. In 2006, a judge terminated the parental rights of the biological parents. Meanwhile, the children have thrived in their new home and are closely bonded to their foster parents and their other brother (Gill’s partner’s biological son, who the two men are also raising).

Martin Gill with the two brothers he hopes to adopt in Florida.


Today the boys, now four and eight years old, have many friends in their North Miami neighborhood, are doing well in school, and are close with the couple’s extended family, which includes two doting grandmothers.A psychologist who evaluated the boys recommended that it would be in the boys’ best interest to be adopted by Gill, testifying that it would be devastating for the boys to remove them from the home.

So that he can adopt the children, Gill is being represented by the ACLU in a challenge to the constitutionality of Florida’s law that automatically bans adoption by gay people.

STATUS:  On November 25, 2008, a juvenile court judge granted the adoption.The attorney general's office immediately filed its notice of appeal.

On December 5, 2008, the ACLU and the children's lawyers filed a request seeking to expedite the appeal by bringing the case directly before the Florida Supreme Court. The request for an expedited appeal was subsequently denied.

Podcast: Martin Gill talks about how the two foster children he is raising with his partner are harmed by Florida's law barring lesbian and gay men from adoption.
YouTube: Learn more about the family at the center of this case.

News
> Child Advocacy Groups Urge Florida Appeals Court To Strike Gay Adoption Ban (6/23/2009)
> ACLU Seeks Immediate Florida Supreme Court Hearing For Gay Adoptive Dad And His Children (12/5/2008)
> Florida Trial Court Opens Way For Lesbians And Gay Men To Adopt (11/25/2008)


Legal Documents
> In re: Gill Trial Transcript (11/25/2008)
> In re: Gill - Trial Court Decision and Order (11/25/2008)


Additional Resources
> In re: Gill - About the Plaintiffs (11/25/2008)
> In re: Gill - Facts About Florida Foster Care (11/25/2008)
> In re: Gill - The Child Welfare Position (11/25/2008)
> In re: Gill - About the Experts (11/25/2008)
> In re: Gill - Summary of Scientific Evidence (11/25/2008)

Click to show/hide issues list
Your Local ACLUcongressional scorecardmultimediadonatepublicationssupport usblogcontact