Stimulus Funds Should Go To Improving Education For Poor And Minority Communities, Says ACLU

Extending Human Rights Policies Essential To Fulfilling International Treaty Obligations

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
CONTACT: (212) 549-2666; media@aclu.org

WASHINGTON – Education funds included in the stimulus bill should be used to further human rights policies in the schools, including programs to close achievement gaps and to improve the quality of education for poor and minority communities across the country, according to a letter the American Civil Liberties Union sent today to Secretary of Education Arne Duncan.

According to the letter, the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act provides an "opportunity not only to make the distribution of educational funds more equitable, but to fulfill fundamental U.S. human rights treaty obligations." 

The ACLU's recommendations include creating innovative human rights education programs to help teachers incorporate universal human rights values into their curriculum materials and addressing the inequitable implementation and provision of education at the federal, state and local levels.

The ACLU's letter is available online at: www.aclu.org/intlhumanrights/racialjustice/38829lgl20090225.html

The full text of the letter is as follows:

February 25, 2009

Mr. Arne Duncan
Secretary
United States Department of Education
400 Maryland Avenue, SW
Washington, D.C. 20202

RE:  Using ARRA Funds to Meet Human Rights Obligations in Education

Dear Mr. Secretary,

We write to congratulate you on your appointment as President Obama's Secretary of Education, and to express our sincere hope that you will use the unprecedented opportunity presented by the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act (ARRA) to further the realization of human rights norms in the U.S.  In particular, we urge you to use the education funds in ARRA to close the achievement gaps in the education system and to improve the quality of education of poor and minority communities across the country, a campaign promise made by the President.  Such a commitment will have the effect of helping the U.S. to meet its international obligations under the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination (CERD).

Achieving quality education for every child in America is a crucial human rights goal that is consistent with President Obama's stated positions.  As President Obama said in his Howard University Convocation speech in September 2007: "It will take a movement to finish what began in Topeka, Kansas and Little Rock, Arkansas.  It will take a movement of Americans from every city and town, of every race and background to stand up and say that no matter what you look like or where you come from, every child in America should have the opportunity to receive the best education this country has to offer.  Every child."

With the passage of ARRA, your department has the opportunity not only to make the distribution of educational funds more equitable, but to fulfill fundamental U.S. human rights treaty obligations.  Under CERD, a fundamental international human rights treaty to which the U.S. is party, federal agencies must review their policies and amend or repeal regulations that have the effect of creating or perpetuating racial discrimination, including those that affect racial and ethnic minorities, indigenous people, women, and immigrant non-citizens. Every four years, the CERD treaty's monitoring committee (CERD Committee) reviews the U.S. government's compliance.  In February 2008, the U.S. appeared before the CERD Committee and reported on its record under CERD and on March 7, 2008, the CERD Committee issued its findings, or Concluding Observations, on the U.S.' compliance with the treaty obligations.  The Committee pressed the U.S. to improve in several areas, including its inadequate implementation and provision of education at the federal, state, and local levels - one of five matters on which our government was to report within one year.  In particular, the Committee focused on the adoption and strengthening the use of affirmative action programs to eliminate discrimination and allowing school districts to voluntarily promote school integration.  The U.S. is to submit its next periodic report and detail progress made on all other issues in 2011.

ARRA offers an unprecedented opportunity to take the obligations of CERD and the recommendations of the CERD Committee into account with regard to the distribution of these educational funds.  In your confirmation testimony before the Senate Committee on Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions, you correctly called education the "civil rights issue of our generation – the only sure path out of poverty and the only way to achieve a more equal and just society."  To promote this enlightened view of education and to achieve conformance with basic human rights standards, the U.S. government should create a more equitable distribution of funds and target them in such a way as to address the compelling concerns cited in the Concluding Observations. 

Beyond these fundamental and obligatory goals, using the discrete funding set aside for teacher quality enhancement and incentive and innovation grants, the Department could also create visionary and innovative special human rights education programs that could help teachers incorporate universal human rights values into their curriculum materials.  Values such as the right to dignity and the right to equality, neglected by the previous administration, would not only meet this universal standard, but also mirror the best of American traditions.

Several human rights organizations, such as Amnesty International USA and the U.S. Human Rights Network, have created successful human rights education and training models in schools, universities, and other educational settings.  Yet the responsibility for developing human rights educational programs should not fall exclusively to NGOs.  Official governmental embrace of fundamental international human rights such as the right to be free from racial discrimination sends a very different message than the mere creation, sponsorship, or promotion of these programs by non-governmental entities.  Many NGOs stand ready to work closely with the government in developing such educational programs and ensuring their effective implementation.

This is a historic opportunity to break with the failed policies of the Bush administration and provide necessary resources aimed at providing equal opportunity for all in a safe, integrated, and equitable educational system.  We welcome the opportunity to discuss with you and with officials in your department the ways in which human rights can strengthen the work of your department and advance your work in educating the nation's children.

We would be pleased to meet with you and your staff to offer suggestions for addressing compliance with CERD educational recommendations through the use of ARRA funds.  Please contact Michael Macleod-Ball at 202-675-2309 if you should have questions or comments or if you wish to advance the discussion on these issues.

Respectfully,

Caroline Frederickson
Director, Washington Legislative Office

Michael W. Macleod-Ball
Chief Legislative and Policy Counsel

Jamil Dakwar
Director, Human Rights Program

cc:  Melody Barnes, Domestic Policy Advisor