American Civil Liberties Union

Federal Court Strikes Down National Security Letters Provision of Patriot Act
In September 2007, in the only legal challenge brought to the NSL provisions of the Patriot Act, a federal court struck down the entirety of the National Security Letter (NSL) provisions of the Patriot Act. Judge Victor Marrero of the Southern District of New York ruled NSLs violate the First Amendment and directly abuse the constitutional separation of powers.

NEWS
> FBI Withdraws Unconstitutional National Security Letter After ACLU And EFF Challenge (5/7/2008)
> ACLU Applauds Senate Scrutiny of Overbroad NSL Authority (4/23/2008)
> ACLU Calls for Investigation into NSL Abuse (4/08/2008)
> ACLU Applauds Senate Scrutiny of Overbroad NSL Authority (4/23/2008)
> ACLU Challenges National Security Letters In Congress And Court (4/15/2008)
> ACLU Asks Court To Affirm Decision Striking Down Patriot Act NSL Provision (3/14/2008)
> FBI Audit Exposes Widespread Abuse Of Patriot Act Powers (3/13/2008)
> Hundreds of New Documents Reveal Expanded Military Role in Domestic Surveillance (10/14/2007)
> Federal Court Strikes Down National Security Letter Provision of Patriot Act (9/6/2007)
> Patriot Act Gag Power is Unconstitutional, ACLU Tells Court (8/15/2007)
> ACLU Outraged at Attorney General's False Testimony (7/10/2007)
> NSL Recipient Disheartened by Reports Gonzales Misled Congress (7/10/2007)
> Government Improperly Withholding Surveillance Records, ACLU Charges (6/28/2007)
> ACLU Applauds Harman Bill to Rein in Power Abused by FBI, Follows House Panel's Questions Regarding National Security Letters (3/28/2007)
> ACLU Urges Senators to Hold FBI Responsible; Says Concerns About National Security Letter Abuses Remain (3/27/2007)

MORE ABOUT NSLs
> Government's Unchecked Power to Censor Speech (9/25/2006)
> See What the Government Gagged (8/19/2004)
> The FBI's Power to Rifle Through Your Records
> Dissent in Post-9/11 America
> Government's Demand for Power After Sept. 11
> What an NSL Looks Like (PDF)
> List of NSLs Issued 10/26/01 to 1/21/03 (PDF)
> Memo on FBI Power to Issue NSLs (PDF)

OTHER PATRIOT ACT LITIGATION
> Lawsuit Challenging Section 215 of the Patriot Act
> Litigation About Patriot Act Surveillance
> Litigation Before the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court
> ACLU Advocacy to Oppose Government Secrecy

 

> Internet Archive > Library Records > Internet Records > FOIA

The National Security Letter provision of the Patriot Act radically expanded the FBI's authority to demand personal records like Web site visits and e-mail addresses without prior court approval. The provision also allows the FBI to forbid or "gag" anyone who receives an NSL from telling anyone about the record demand.

Since the Patriot Act was authorized in 2001, further relaxing restrictions on the FBI's use of the power, the number of NSLs issued has seen an astronomical increase. Reports previously indicated a hundred-fold increase to 30,000 NSLs issued annually, but a March 2007 report from the Justice Department's Inspector General puts the actual number at over 143,000 NSLs issued between 2003 and 2005. The same investigation also found serious FBI abuses of regulations and numerous potential violations of the law.

The ACLU has challenged this Patriot Act statute in court with two cases: one involving an Internet Service Provider; the second a group of librarians. In both cases, the judges found the gags are unconstitutional.

In addition, the ACLU filed a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request to learn more about the Department of Defense and CIA's use of National Security Letters. In October 2007, the ACLU received over 500 documents from its request. (More >>)

NSL ABUSES
> Roadmap of Justice Department Review of the FBI's Use of NSLs
> National Security Letters by the Numbers
> 5 Myths About the Bush Administration's Use of NSLs
> 12 Questions Congress Needs to Ask
> ACLU Analysis and Recommendations (3/9/2007)

ABUSE OF POWER ISSUES:


Press Releases
Publications
Legal Documents
Legislative Documents
Resources
Fact Sheets

P.U.C. / FOIA ACTION MAP:
PUC/FOIA Map
Learn about the challenge to unchecked spying in your state >>


Find Out What You Can Do
Help Defend the Constitution and Bill of Rights

Your Local ACLUcongressional scorecardmultimediaforumspublicationssupport usstorecontact