ACLU Urges Senate to Oppose Voter ID Amendment to Immigration Reform Bill (6/5/2007)
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE Contact: media@dcaclu.org
Washington, DC - The American Civil Liberties Union today urged the Senate to
oppose Senator Mitch McConnell’s amendment to S. 1348, the immigration reform
bill, which is expected to receive a floor vote as soon as this evening. Senator
McConnell’s amendment would require voters to present a government-issued photo
ID in order to vote in federal elections. This requirement imposes an
unnecessary and undue burden on the exercise of the fundamental right to vote
for millions of Americans who are eligible, registered, and qualified to
vote.
"The right to vote, and to have every vote counted, is the most important
civil right of all," said Caroline Fredrickson, director of the ACLU Washington
Legislative Office. "Congress should be in the business of encouraging full
participation in our democratic process, not throwing up obstacles between
Americans and the voting booth. Proposals like the McConnell amendment are one
of the greatest threats to fair and equal voting rights today. The Senate should
oppose this and any proposal that would limit qualified Americans’ ability to
exercise their right to vote."
The ACLU opposes voter ID proposals because:
- No eligible citizen should have to pay to vote. For voters
who don’t have a photo ID, requiring them to purchase one in order to vote would
be equivalent to a poll tax. Photo IDs cost money — even if the IDs themselves
are "free," the birth certificates, passports, or other documents required to
get an ID are not.
- Voter ID requirements pose a substantial hardship for some citizens.
Voter ID requirements will have a disproportionate and unfair impact on
low-income, racial and ethnic minority voters, senior citizens, voters with
disabilities and others who do not have a photo ID, nor the money or ability to
acquire one.
- Voting is a fundamental right. Senator McConnell’s amendment would
restrict, not increase, access to the voting booth. Rather than erecting hurdles
that prevent Americans from voting, lawmakers should be working to ensure that
every eligible voter is allowed to vote, and that every vote counts.
"The McConnell amendment amounts to a solution in search of a problem," said
Deborah J. Vagins, ACLU Policy Counsel for Civil Rights. "Supporters of this
amendment argue it’s necessary to require photo IDs in order to combat efforts
to skew elections, but recent evidence has shown no proof of widespread
organized voter fraud. This amendment only serves to disfranchise American
citizens."
|