Because freedom can't protect itself
After you get the pictures etc released
and add fuel to the fire for the terrorists and we are again attacked.
This time possibly killing 10's of thousands instead of 3000 how will your
organization feel? Will you say it was
worth it? This is a war against the terrorists, do you think we can just sit down with them and give them a big hug and they will give us information to prevent another attack. You are putting are military in great danger and I for one am proud of our military, they fight with uniforms against people who do not and are glad to blow themselves up in a group of innocent people, yet you want to protect them. You are off your rocker!!
Ah yes, torturing a 14 year old boy must have made those dickless cowards feel powerful!
So true Roger the chicken hawks scream
for war but do you notice how often they
talk about how proud they are of those in uniform but never about their own uniforms.
Dennis - Why would you blame the people who support the law rather than the people who broke it? Better a thousand innocents be executed than allow a single terrorist go free?
Hey PAIN(in the arse)!
I wore a USMC Uniform smart arse....and know perfectly well the real deal!
What Uniform have you wore?
Again...you call it Torture...I call it extracting information!!
I have a question for you Libs....Would you call Beheading *Collateral Damage*...or Murder?
Were the Victims of 9/11 *Collateral Damage*....or Murdered?
Were the tens of thousands of Kurds *Collateral Damage*....or Murdered?
I'll bet all of those VICTIMS would rather be alive.....What say YOU?
Despite understanding ACLU’s empathy and excitement on Jawad’s case in particular; I am very concerned about the “mission creep” of the ALCU. From my perspective as both an American Soldier and an American citizen, it appears the ALCU is drifting from becoming an American organization to a global organization. It appears as if the ACLU is now operating outside of the boundaries of the US protecting the rights of non-Americans with the US Constitution. I would hate to see such a historic and great organization as the ACLU transformed into or becoming a mental icon to millions of Americans as a pro bono terrorist lawyer firm. My opinion is that these terrorists are not Americans and the ACLU should not ruin its reputation by falling on its sword in defense of these evil non-American terrorists.
Let’s take a look at the ALCU mission statement, “The ACLU is our nation's guardian of liberty, working daily in courts, legislatures and communities to defend and preserve the individual rights and liberties that the Constitution and laws of the United States guarantee everyone in this country”. What does the above mission statement have anything to do with what is going on at Gitmo?
As a military officer for the last 12 years, I have spent 29 months in Iraq and 6 months in Bosnia being a fellow guardian of our nation’s liberty. I am very proud of my years of service and proud of my fellow American brother and sisters in service who comprise the guardians to our nation’s liberty. It disturbs me that my fellow guardians of our nation’s liberty, the ACLU, is more concerned about a terrorist’s rights than an American’s rights and our way of life that the terrorist wants to destroy. Of course these terrorists are going to say they were coerced and tortured, they all will say it if it will facilitate them getting released with the assistance of their ACLU counsel. We cannot take these evil people on their word, they are being trained to lie if captured. They are playing the ACLU and abusing the American Constitution. These terrorists should not be protected by our Constitution and the ACLU because they are not Americans! My fellow guardians of our nation’s liberty have recaptured about 60 of these dangerous terrorists back on the battlefield after they have been released from GITMO alone. Their recidivism rate is comparable to sexual predators of children. Let me assure you, these terrorists are not the victims and we should not feel the overwhelming need to feel bad for them.
I believe there are probably some problems with the military commission process, but to say “there is no question” that they are unlawful is a one-sided opinion and not a holistic view of the problem of what to do with these terrorist detainees. I recommend we continue the military commission process, keep GITMO open or find a suitable alternative outside of the US, and that the US military and the ACLU continue to be the guardians of our nation’s liberty and defend and preserve the individual rights and liberties that the Constitution and laws of the United States guarantee everyone in this country…of Americans that is.
Major David Williams, student, Command and General Staff College, U.S. Army Combined Arms Center, Fort Leavenworth, Kansas. The views expressed in this ACLU blog are those of the author and do not reflect the official position or policies of the Department of the Army, Department of Defense, or the U.S. Government.
If the detainees get out and do another attack , I hope Americans all over the country grab their guns and KILL every ACLU member in America. We are not standing for this. America lets hunt them down.
More information about formatting options
Get breaking news on issues you care about
Congress: Restore the Voting Rights Act
Sign up for the ACLU Action newsletter.
Chip in to help protect all of our rights and liberties.
© ACLU, 125 Broad Street, 18th Floor, New York NY 10004
This is the website of the American Civil Liberties Union and the ACLU Foundation.
Learn more about these two components of the ACLU.