The Muslim Ban Is a Muslim Ban, the ACLU Argued in Court 

As the gavel sounded on Monday afternoon, the Richmond, Virginia, courtroom quieted. In a room of rich green carpet, great hanging chandeliers, and dark wood, the Fourth Circuit prepared to listen to a lawyer from the government argue with the ACLU’s Omar Jadwat about the Muslim ban.

Outside, a couple hundred protesters marched around the courthouse shouting, “No hate, no fear, Muslims are welcome here!”

“My great-grandparents were immigrants,” said Louis Gary, 59, an IT manager from Henrico County, Virginia, saying he thought it was “foolish” to categorize all citizens of six Muslim-majority countries as a threat.

Inside, some 13 judges — the entire Fourth Circuit, minus two judges who recused themselves — fired questions at attorneys about the Muslim ban. Normally, a three-judge panel would hear the case, but the court of appeals decided to bypass normal procedures and have the whole circuit weigh in on whether or not President Trump’s executive order violates First Amendment prohibitions against the government’s denigration of a religion.

Maryland U.S. District Court Judge Theodore D. Chuang had written in his March ruling that the “history of public statements continues to provide a con­vincing case that the purpose of the Second Executive Order remains the realization of the long-envisioned Muslim ban.”

On Monday, the Fourth Circuit judges barraged government attorney Jeffrey B. Wall, the acting U.S. solicitor general, with questions about whether they should consider campaign promises Trump made to ban Muslims from entering the U.S.

“What he said was that Islam hates us. He said we have a problem with Muslims in the United States.”

Wall attempted to paint the Muslim ban as reasonable, a mere “pause” to study the existing procedures to vet travelers from six countries, and insisted it had nothing to do with the countries being predominantly Muslim.

“This is not a Muslim ban,” Wall said. “It has nothing to do with religion. Its operation has nothing to do with religion.”

He insisted that Trump’s call for “a total and complete shutdown of Muslims entering the United States” was mere campaign rhetoric. “Candidates talk about things on the campaign trail all the time,” Wall said.

Some of the judges on the panel seemed persuaded by the argument. Judge Paul V. Niemeyer asked how far back one should go in looking at a president’s prior statements. “Can we look at his college speeches?" he said. "How about his speeches to businessmen about 20 years ago, should we look at that?” 

But other judges pushed back, suggesting that what candidate Trump said he intended to do during the campaign was relevant to what he actually did.

“He’s never repudiated what he said about the Muslim ban,” said Judge Robert B. King.

Judge Henry F. Floyd put it even more starkly: “Is there anything other than willful blindness that would prevent us from looking at those?” he said.

In making his case that the president’s order was motivated by animus towards Islam, Jadwat, the director of the ACLU's Immigrants' Rights Project, said, “What he said was that Islam hates us. He said we have a problem with Muslims in the United States.”

Jadwat also pointed out that the president’s promise to ban Muslims remained online on his campaign website. Almost simultaneously, the statements were taken down yesterday, after a reporter asked White House Press Secretary Sean Spicer about them.

The government argued that the courts shouldn’t second-guess the president’s national security decisions. Some of the judges seemed to agree.

“Is the executive not entitled to some deference?” asked Judge Dennis W. Shedd.

“Deference can’t be a reason to violate the Establishment Clause,” said Jadwat, referring to the clause of the First Amendment that prohibits discrimination on the basis of religion.

“If you’re right about the order in this case, I don’t know where it stops,” said one judge.

“I think the question is not so much where it ends, but if it starts at all,” said Jadwat.

Jadwat focused on the real impact the decision would have on plaintiffs. One is a Syrian-born college student in North Carolina waiting to be reunited with her sister and her sister’s husband and children, who had escaped their country after their house was destroyed by Syrian government bombardment. They eventually ended up in Yemen, one of the few countries to accept Syrian refugees without visas, and got United Nations' status as refugees. But war broke out in Yemen too, leaving them under bombardment and lacking adequate food, clean water, or electricity.

The ACLU and National Immigration Law Center also brought the case to the Fourth Circuit on behalf of organizations including the International Refugee Assistance Project, which aids refugees; HIAS, a refugee resettlement organization founded as the Hebrew Immigrant Aid Society; and the Middle East Studies Association, an academic association whose members’ travel was restricted by the ban.

There is no word on when the Fourth Circuit will rule, but the Ninth Circuit Appeals Court will hear another challenge to Trump’s Muslim ban on May 15 in Seattle.

View comments (27)
Read the Terms of Use


Thank you ACLU for speaking up for the constitution, and for every decent rational person in the USA. The ban doesn't make us safer, and it makes anti-US rhetoric more powerful. And it's inhumane and contrary to our values as a country.

Trolls please note -- I won't be reading responses to this comment, so don't bother.


And you snowflakes will be the first to cry wolf when they muslims blow up your civic center or something. You people just don't get it. Stay in CA and don't cross the state line we don't want you


Very controversial topic!
i just going to write my essay about similar theme for


The ACLU has proven itself to not be an organization for the rights and identity of all Americans. The ACLU is an anti-white, anti-male and anti-status quo organization acting as an affront to the status quo, and therefore is an organization focused on the hatred of the identity of the West, the identity of Capitalism, and the identity of the American. A gross and repugnant organizaiton.


ra unik untuk pria dan wanita pegolf yang telah Jual besi hollow Jual besi hollow Toko besi siku Jual pipa besi Toko pipa besi baja sch 40 sch 80 undangan pernikahan bentuk tas Supplier Besi H beam Agen Wiremesh Besi baja Jual plat kapal besi baja Pabrik besi beton master steel ms Supplier besi hollow Supplier besi hollow Toko pipa besi baja sch 40 sch 80 Supplier pipa besi Toko besi hollow undangan pernikahan ada fotonya Supplier Besi Beton Toko Wiremesh Besi baja Supplier plat kapal besi baja Pabrik besi beton ksty Toko besi hollow Toko besi hollow Toko Plat besi Toko pipa besi Toko besi beton Sni Ulir Polos undangan pernikahan aneh Jual Wiremesh Besi baja Toko plat kapal besi baja Pabrik besi beton krakatau steel Agen besi hollow Agen besi hollow Toko besi h beam Agen pipa besi Toko besi wf baja undangan pernikahan amplop Pabrik Welded Beam T beam King Queen Cross Castellated Beam Harga Wiremesh Besi baja Agen plat kapal besi baja Pabrik besi beton jcac Pabrik besi hollow Pabrik besi hollow Toko besi wf Pabrik pipa besi Toko besi unp undangan pernikahan batik Pabrik Bondek Cor Pabrik Wiremesh Besi baja Pabrik plat kapal besi baja Pabrik besi beton interworld steel is Distributor pipa besi Distributor pipa besi Toko wiremesh Distributor sch 40 Toko besi siku undangan pernikahan murah Pabrik Atap Spandek Sni Distributor Besi Siku Baja Distributor besi siku baja Pabrik besi beton gunung garuda Harga pipa besi Harga pipa besi Toko besi unp Harga sch 40 Toko Plat besi plat kapal undangan pernikahan online sewa villa puncak Pabrik Plat Bordes Kembang Supplier Besi Siku Baja Harga besi siku baja Pabrik besi beton delcoprima Jual pipa besi Jual pipa besi Toko besi cnp Jual sch 40 Toko besi h beam baja undangan pernikahan anti mainstream Pabrik Plat Besi Hitam Agen Besi Siku Baja Jual besi siku baja Pabrik besi beton cakra steel cs Supplier pipa besi Supplier pipa besi Toko besi hollow Supplier sch 40 Toko besi cnp undangan pernikahan cantik dan murah Pabrik Plat Kapal Bki Krakatau Steel Toko Besi Siku Baja Supplier besi siku baja Pabrik besi beton bjku Toko pipa besi Toko pipa besi Toko besi beton Sni Ulir Polos Toko sch 40 undangan pernikahan unik Pabrik Jual Besi Siku Baja Jual Besi Siku Baja Toko besi siku baja Pabrik besi beton Sni Ulir Polos Agen pipa besi Agen pipa besi Agen sch 40 Supplier besi Wf Baja undangan pernikahan yang unik Pabrik Besi Unp Baja Profil Kanal Harga Besi Siku Baja Agen besi siku baja Pabrik besi beton ais Pabrik pipa besi Pabrik pipa besi Supplier stainless steel Pabrik sch 40 Supplier bondek undangan pernikahan lucu Pabrik Besi Cnp Profil Baja Gording Pabrik Besi Siku Baja Pabrik besi siku baja Pabrik besi beton Distributor sch 40 Distributor sch 40 Supplier atap spandek Distributor besi Pipa sch 80 baja Supplier wiremesh undangan pernikahan bunga Pabrik Besi Hollow Distributor Besi Unp Baja Distributor besi wf jasa konstruksi baja Harga sch 40 Harga sch 40 Supplier baja ringan Harga besi Pipa sch 80 baja Supplier pipa besi baja sch 40 sch 80 undangan pernikahan islami Pabrik Wiremesh Supplier Besi Unp Baja Harga besi wf Jual sch 40 Jual sch 40 Supplier bondek Jual besi Pipa sch 80 baja Supplier besi hollow undangan pernikahan ada foto Pabrik Besi Pipa Baja Schedule 80\ Agen Besi Unp Baja Jual besi wf Jual Jaket Parka Jual Jaket Parka Jaket Parka Jaket Parka Jual Jaket Parka Jual Jaket Parka Jaket Parka Jaket Parka undangan pernikahan kalender undangan pernikahan bahasa inggris islam undangan pernikahan islami undangan pernikahan unik dan murah undangan pernikahan modern undangan pernikahan online undangan pernikahan undangan pernikahan amplop surat undangan pernikahan simple undangan pernikahan murah undangan pernikahan unik undangan pernikahan artis undangan pernikahan modern undangan pernikahan artis undangan pernikahan arab undangan pernikahan undangan pernikahan



Isla Ashley

I was fully blank about it before reading this post.


Stay Informed