ICE Is Illegally Imprisoning Asylum Seekers

Ansly Damus has been locked up for one year, four months, and counting. Held behind bars by Immigration and Customs Enforcement, he has not been outside for more than a year. His crime? In October 2016, Damus fled violent, political persecution in Haiti. When he arrived in the U.S., he presented himself to immigration authorities and applied for asylum. He passed his “credible fear” interview. And then a judge granted him asylum — not once, but twice.

Damus committed no crime, and yet the U.S. government has put him behind bars. He’s not alone — thousands of other asylum seekers are also being held in jails across the country.


Today, the ACLU and its partners, the Center for Gender and Refugee Studies, Human Rights First, and Covington & Burling LLP, filed a class action lawsuit challenging the Trump administration’s pattern of illegally locking up immigrants who are seeking asylum in the United States. The plaintiffs are fleeing persecution, torture, or death in their countries of origin. Like Damus, they all followed procedure and presented themselves at the border to apply for asylum, were screened by a government official, and found to have a credible asylum claim that should be heard in court. Instead of offering a humane response, the Trump administration has locked them up indefinitely while their cases are adjudicated.

The arbitrary imprisonment of people like Damus is part of the administration’s larger strategy of deterring immigrants from seeking refuge in the U.S. even though our laws permit them to. This same cruel and abusive deterrence strategy underlies tactics like brutally separating parents from their children, and criminally prosecuting individuals who cross the border to seek asylum.

The administration’s detention of asylum seekers is not only cruel and wasteful. It violates the Constitution, breaks U.S. immigration laws and international law, and goes against the Department of Homeland Security’s written policy.

The Fifth Amendment prohibits the government from depriving any person, regardless of citizenship, of their liberty without due process of law. Due process requires a valid reason for putting a person behind bars, and it also requires that meaningful procedures are in place to make sure detention actually serves those goals. The Constitution does not permit the government to take people’s liberty away arbitrarily, regardless of whether the Trump administration wants to send a message that asylum seekers “need not apply.”

Moreover, immigration laws require the government to consider the facts in each case to determine if the individual is a flight risk or a danger to public safety before it detains that person. Similarly, international law prohibits the use of detention to deter asylum seekers from pursuing their claims, without an individualized determination that detention is justified because the person is a danger or flight risk. But the administration is jailing asylum seekers without providing them a meaningful opportunity to show that they don’t need to be locked up in the first place.

Finally, the indiscriminate detention of asylum seekers violates the Department of Homeland Security’s own policies. In 2009, the Obama administration issued a directive instructing ICE Field Offices to grant release on humanitarian parole to asylum seekers, provided that they met a series of stringent requirements: pass their credible fear screening (an interview in which an immigration official determines whether there’s a “significant possibility” the person is eligible for asylum); prove their identity; pose no danger to the community; and provide an address where they will be living and commit to appearing for court dates.

Tell DHS to stop the illegal detention of asylum seekers

This directive is still in place. Yet in practice, people are being illegally detained for months on end, even though they met the directive’s requirements.

Ansly Damus, for example, poses no danger to anyone and has strong claims for protection under our laws. He is an ethics teacher from Grand-Rivière-du-Nord in Haiti and was forced to flee Haiti because of political persecution by “La Meezorequin,” known as the Shark Bones Army, an armed gang that supported a local official, Benjamin Ocenjac. In one of his seminars, he cited Ocenjac as an example of a politician who had used gangs to terrorize the population. As retribution, members of La Meezorequin attacked Damus while he was riding home on his motorcycle, beat him, set his motorcycle on fire, and threatened to kill him. Fearing for his life, he fled Haiti 10 days later.

In October 2016, Damus traveled to the border at Calexico, California, presented himself to the immigration authorities, and requested asylum. After interviewing him, an asylum officer verified that he had a credible asylum claim and referred him for a hearing before an immigration judge. The judge then granted him asylum twice. But because the government appealed each asylum grant, he’s been locked up ever since in a detention facility in Chardon, Ohio, where detainees are kept in windowless rooms. “I have not breathed fresh air or felt the sun on my face,” he says, “and I never know if it is cold or hot outside, if the sun is out, and if the seasons are changing.”

Damus’ case reflects a nationwide problem. Our lawsuit focuses on five ICE field offices covering detention centers in California, Michigan, New Jersey, New Mexico, Ohio, Pennsylvania, and Texas. In 2013, these field offices granted 95 percent of asylum seekers’ applications for humanitarian parole. Since Trump took office, their rates of parole grants have dropped to nearly zero. It’s estimated that more than 1,000 asylum seekers have been denied humanitarian parole in these five ICE districts alone.

Immigrants like Ansly Damus are exactly the people the directive was designed to protect, yet the Trump administration is ignoring it entirely. Donald Trump may want to keep immigrants out of America, but he is not above the law or the Constitution as he pursues his inhumane agenda.

View comments (48)
Read the Terms of Use


Asylum seekers are not illegal. In order to be categorized as an asylum seeker, you have to present yourself to the federal government and make an application, you know, the legal process one needs to take?


It is because they are anti-American and are actively undermining our country with the goal of weakening the US to the same level of India and China. It begins with taking control of the media and the universities and destroying the constitution and waging war on religion. Yes, the superdelegates are "tearing up this country" as they support Louis Farrakhan and follow his hatred.

Jeb Bartlett

Melania Trump was an 'illegal alien' until she married The Donald, having outstayed her visa. Yes, we liberals know what 'illegal' means. And when The Donald goes on his rants about 'chain migration', he might also look to his own family, because after Melania married into a wealthy family, she started bringing her family members over from Slovenia.


These are Terrible Times...


Let the wall be built soon
Border jumpers will reduce


It’s clear, if you are a foreigner and have a different color regardless what status you have not welcome in the US anymore..... . Political games. Very sad.


Different color other than brown? Check the stats and you'll see that "brown" is the favored skin color when it comes to immigration. However, it would be more accurate to say that Mexicans are the group with the biggest advantage by far followed by people from a handful of countries whose populations are mostly "brown" and China (are Chinese people considered "brown"?).

Mr Mister

This is thr same ACLU that is supporting gangs by fighting legal injunctions against gang activity. Usefull idiots give them money to help illegal immigrants and they spend it helping gang members victimize poor people.

Jeb Bartlett

I have just joined the ACLU for the first time in my life. I am thrilled, and cannot figure out what took me so long. Thank you all for your hard work. My major reason for joining is the threat to marginalized communities by ICE, and the heroic responses by some of the organizations I have read about. I am proud to be supporting this effort.

Call me a liberal, if you want, but If you want to insult me, call me a republican.


Obama was still President when this guy was locked up and that link you provided to a supposed international law actually goes to a guideline issued by the UN. I am forced to conclude that your article is not credible.


Stay Informed