No Public Relations Campaign Can Rehabilitate the Image of Immigration and Customs Enforcement

We were all afraid of the knocks on our door, especially if it happened early in the morning. We all knew what it could mean — ICE, la Migra, Immigration and Customs Enforcement.

There was always a second of pause, a moment of silence where my parents and I would look at each other — the slight silent hesitation where a thousand thoughts ran through all of our heads. Who will take care of the children when they take us? Do you remember where all our important documents are? You remember who you’re supposed to call first? Take care of your siblings. We love you.

Many immigrant families know this drill. ICE has built a reputation of shattering families and destroying immigrant communities. Recently, ICE started a public relations campaign where they are attempting to create an image of themselves as “fair and effective."

ACLU ICE tweet

But here at the ACLU, we have a better understanding of the practices that ICE has carried and will continue to carry out under the Trump Administration. President Trump ordered an additional 10,000 new ICE agents, tripling the current number, to implement his enforcement agenda. An agenda that pays lip service to going after only the “bad hombres ” when it actually seeks to target all undocumented immigrants regardless of their criminal history or ties to this country.

President Trump has essentially given ICE free range to do as they please. The proverbial “shackles” have come off, creating panic among immigrant communities. Widespread constitutional violations, including racial profiling and unlawful stops, have contributed to the public image ICE has within communities. 

A high school in Maryland with a high Latinx population saw a decline in attendance as deportation fears rose. Parents avoided sending their kids to school fearing they would be picked up by ICE while they were dropping them off or picking them up.

The ICE-induced panic extends beyond the classroom and into our nation’s courthouses. Experts have seen a sharp decline in Latinas reporting domestic violence and sexual assault. A woman identified by the initials I.E.G. was arrested by half a dozen ICE agents in a courthouse in El Paso County while seeking a protective order against her abusive partner. El Paso County Attorney Jo Anne Bernal speculated that the only other person who could have tipped ICE off was her alleged abuser. Victims are not reporting crimes and even dropping their cases fearing deportation.

Our courthouses cannot thrive if they do not allow all individuals access to justice. ICE is not enforcing the law but preventing the law from being enforced, disrupting public safety and ensuring that crimes, such as domestic violence, go unreported.

Fortunately, judges across the United States are speaking out. Chief Justice of the California Supreme Court Cantil Sakauye sent a letter to Attorney General Jeff Sessions and Homeland Security Secretary John Kelly, urging them to end the practice of courthouse arrests.  Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of New Jersey Stuart Rabner has also written a letter to Kelly.

In fact, ICE, despite claiming to be “fair and effective” in this new PR strategy, has quite a history of detaining and deporting the least expected individuals: American citizens. Data from 2010 suggests that over 4,000 American citizens were either detained or deported in that year alone.

If this is how ICE views its operations as “fair and effective,” then it leaves much to be desired.

View comments (17)
Read the Terms of Use

Anonymous

That sounds terrific! Think of the Canadian parents ecstatic at saving $10000s of dollars and perhaps their college-age child's life from disastrous military engagements by returning home! They can also have affordable healthcare. And they can thank the myopic, apathetic, and lethargic US citizens who could have voted but didn't (disenfranchised citizens kept away by oppressive county election laws have my sympathy) for giving them the impetus to improve their lives.

Dead Sherriff

I shot your sherriff, but I didn't shoot your deputy.

Anchor Citizens

Send the English back to England along with their anchor ancestors. Same for the Italians, Irish, Germans, and especially dirty ass Poles.

Anonymous

Many of the people you're talking about came here as kids or young adults. They've paid taxes, raised kids, and contributed to society. The reason we have the system we have now is that everyone -- including most Republican Senators -- thought that immigration reform was coming, and these people would have a path to citizenship. Jeff Sessions was a far-right holdout and was able to block Jeff Flake's move toward immigration reform in 2013. This was preposterous, because the impact of immigration from a services perspective was far worse in AZ than it was in AL. Jeff Sessions' far-right wing agenda is only in power because of his early backing of Trump. Most Republicans do not believe that we should send mothers and fathers, heads of household, taxpayers, back. And ICE is just being lazy, trying to hit numbers with people who should have a path to citizenship. They are not saving anyone from violent criminals -- they are behaving unconstitutionally, encouraging local jurisdictions to violate fourth amendment rights. These immigrants contribute disproportionately to our GDP, our societies and our communities. They should stay, and ICE should earn its money doing the right thing and deporting violent criminals.

Anonymous

None of what you have said refutes that they are tearing families apart. Just that you think it's ok for them to do so.

Anonymous

From the article you commented on:
"Data from 2010 suggests that over 4,000 American citizens were either detained or deported in that year alone."
These families of American citizens destroyed themselves?
I think your reading skills need improvement.

Anonymous

I love how they only go after families, you never hear of ice arresting cartels and such, thats much too dangerous for them they'd probably shit their pants, much better send 6 agents to arrest a middle aged mom, in their head it probably makes them seem strong and masculine ffs

Pages

Stay Informed