The Muslim Ban: What Just Happened?

Earlier this week, the Supreme Court allowed President Trump’s Muslim ban to go into full effect while it is being litigated. Prior to the court’s Dec. 4 order, large portions of the ban were blocked by preliminary injunctions in the cases of IRAP v. Trump and Hawaii v. Trump.

Let’s be clear: The fact that the ban is moving forward is devastating for Muslims in the United States and abroad — and for anyone who values the fundamental constitutional principle of religious equality. The Establishment Clause of the First Amendment prohibits the government from favoring or disfavoring one religion among others, but that’s precisely what President Trump’s Muslim ban does.

It’s important to recognize that the Supreme Court did not express any views about the merits of the ban — and in particular, it did not find or suggest that the ban is constitutional or compatible with our immigration laws. We have been challenging this and previous versions of the ban since President Trump started down this path, and the courts that have reached the merits have repeatedly found the bans unconstitutional and illegal. That is one reason why we believe that the ban will ultimately be struck down.

On Dec. 8, we will be in court, along with our co-counsel from the National Immigration Law Center and the International Refugee Assistance Project and colleagues from Muslim Advocates, the Council on American-Islamic Relations, the Brennan Center for Justice, and Americans United for Separation of Church and State, fighting to strike down the Muslim ban in its entirety. Here’s what you need to know.

Wasn’t the Muslim ban blocked last January?

On Jan. 27, President Trump signed an executive order that prohibited citizens from seven Muslim-majority countries from entering the United States for 90 days, suspended the entry of all refugees for at least 120 days, and barred Syrian refugees indefinitely.

The damage was immediate — thousands of travelers were detained at airports and families were separated from their loved ones — but so was the pushback. Thousands of people, including members of Congress, showed up at airports across the country in support of Muslims, shouting, “Let them in.” The next day, a federal court blocked deportations under the ban in a case brought by the ACLU and partners, and more court orders quickly followed.

Rather than defend the ban in court, the president issued a new version on March 6. Once again, this Muslim ban was successfully challenged and blocked in a suit brought by the ACLU and partners as well as another case brought by the state of Hawaii. Appeals from these decisions were set for argument before the Supreme Court on Oct. 10, but on Sept. 24, the Trump administration issued a new ban proclamation, thus replacing the second Muslim ban with a third. We returned to district court, securing a new order blocking large portions of the latest ban, which was in effect until Monday when the Supreme Court issued its most recent order.

So what did the Supreme Court’s order do exactly?

The Supreme Court allowed the government to enforce all of the Sep. 24 proclamation, parts of which were previously blocked by lower courts while the case is being litigated.

mytubethumbplay
%3Ciframe%20allowfullscreen%3D%22%22%20frameborder%3D%220%22%20height%3D%22315%22%20src%3D%22https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FAbgXX2OXyjM%3Fautoplay%3D1%26version%3D3%22%20thumb%3D%22%2Ffiles%2Fweb17-muslimbanwhathappened-560x315.jpg%22%20width%3D%22560%22%3E%3C%2Fiframe%3E
Privacy statement. This embed will serve content from youtube.com.

 

Who can be banned? And when does it go into effect?

The ban targets citizens of six majority-Muslim countries: Chad, Iran, Libya, Somalia, Syria, and Yemen. The government can now deny visas to nationals of the six banned countries, including people who have a “bona fide” relationship with a person or entity in the United States. This includes relatives of both U.S. citizens and green card holders from the listed countries as well as other visa applicants. The ban affects 150 million people, the vast majority of whom are Muslim.

The ban also puts restrictions on North Korea and Venezuela, two countries that are not Muslim-majority. Their inclusion will have almost no practical effect. In 2016, North Korea accounted for 61 visas that would have been affected by the ban, a tiny fraction of the tens of millions of people who come to this country each year. And only certain Venezuelan government officials and their families are affected, and those individuals are only barred from obtaining tourist and similar visas.

The Supreme Court’s order permits the government to implement the full version of the ban immediately. The order should not impact people who already have valid visas to enter the United States. If you have a valid visa but are stopped at the airport because you are from a banned country, or you know someone in that situation, email airport@refugeerights.org.

Is this version different from the previous two bans?

Yes, it is even worse. There is no time limit. Instead of having a so-called “temporary pause,” the president has instituted an indefinite and potentially permanent ban.

How does this ban impact people’s lives?

This ban tears at the heart of Muslim communities in the United States, reminding them daily that the president openly discriminates against their faith and has instituted policies that embody this prejudice and bigotry. It will separate Muslims in the United States from their family members abroad. It takes away the ability of U.S. citizens and green card holders to live with, or even be visited by, spouses, parents, children, grandparents, and other family members. Among other things, it will exclude friends and family from weddings, graduations, and funerals; prevent grandparents, uncles, and aunts from holding and caring for newborns; deny final visits to ailing relatives; deprive American audiences and scholars of the ability to hear from and collaborate with individuals from the banned countries; and bar talented, promising young people from U.S. universities and companies. The impact of this discriminatory ban is tremendous.

The ban bars citizens of Chad, Iran, Libya, Somalia, Syria, and Yemen from securing immigrant visas, which result in lawful permanent resident status, or a green card, including family-based and employment-based visas. Various nonimmigrant visas — like tourist and temporary business visas, student visas, and exchange visas — are also eliminated for people from Chad, Libya, Syria, Yemen, and Iran as noted in the chart below:

Muslim Ban What Happened

Those who are not impacted by the ban include:

  • lawful permanent residents
  • dual nationals of a banned country and a non-banned country
  • people who had a valid visa before the ban went into effect
  • people traveling on a diplomatic visa
  • people who have been granted asylum, withholding of removal, protection under the U.N. Convention against Torture, or advanced parole
  • refugees who have already been admitted to the United States.

Under the ban, there will be a case-by-case waiver process, where the burden lies on the applicant to demonstrate undue hardship, the absence of a threat to national security and public safety, and that their entry is in the interest of the United States.

As the ACLU and partners challenge the ban in court, what can the public do?

In order to continue to be successful in our efforts to stop the president’s Muslim ban in court, we need everyone’s help.

  • Visit www.NoMuslimBanEver.com, and find resources to you can organize with your friends, family members, and colleagues.
  • Raise your voice, along with the voices of others in your community, to say to local government officials, members of Congress, and the president: We will not stand for discrimination against Muslims in the United States. We demand that you take a stand against the Muslim ban.
  • Tell Congress to rescind the ban immediately.
    View comments (95)
    Read the Terms of Use

    Richard Richard...

    Letting in people from terrorist countries and not knowing who they are is no good for security or the safety of the American people. Security and safety has nothing to do with religion.

    Anonymous

    Islam is a violent political ideology. Read the Quran. Whether some Muslims choose to practice their beliefs or not, the Quran clearly states Islam will not tolerate any other beliefs. Period. Have you seen the pictures of Iran and Afghanistan from the mid-20th century compared to now? Islam degrades. The plan is to overtake a country, kill all non believers and institute Sharia law. If this isn't a threat to any nation I don't know what is.

    Anonymous

    actually, go read the Quran. try to find where on earth it says anything like that

    Anonymous

    you go read the quran and hadeeth and what the rouah said, since these are your pillars in islam im addition to you muftees where they bend the religion as they want whenever u want.
    Doesn't it say that god's only religion is islam? what does this mean, that other religions are your friends?
    non muslim blood os halal for you?
    Im with the ban in all non muslim countries and deporting all.

    Anonymous

    They are like cancer, once they enter the country it will become a nightmare within the next 5-10 years, and you will find them everywhere shoving their religion down everyone's life and daily routine, sheiks everywhere telling you all what you do is haram and agaisnt god's will. It starts with thier request of "respecting" their traditions, ramadan, halal...etc, and ends with telling you that all non muslim women are whores and that "god's religion is islam" and everyone else is infidel.... Ban them from all non muslim counties at any cost or you will lose your country down the road.
    Open your eyes.

    Anonymous

    You do realize Christians do the exact same thing, right? Take the ignorance out of your throat and stop trying to find ways to remove people who are different from you because of race and religion. Every race and religion has blood on their hands, so grow up. They have ISIS and we have the KKK, which is still active behind the scenes. Slavery in America was only recently removed as well. White people have their own issues to work out without removing attention from themselves by ignorantly blaming others to feel better about themselves and their mistakes.

    Anonymous

    Awful, how immature is Trump? White people do more damage and do terrorism themselves. He's just trying to avoid the blame on his own race, promote discrimination, and more crap because he can't handle the real world and what's on it. He is unrealistic and closed minded, which represents America as well. This makes the country look immature, brainless, and unable to cope with the fear caused by differences in the world. This ban is disgusting and inhumane, way to go Trump.

    Harry

    I don't think so it is a right decision which he had taken because it will impact on the negative effect on the USA. Anyhow, I am taking awest coast tours usa.

    MIKE banit

    I have no problem with any person outside the USA coming here unless they're coming here to get on welfare & drive brand new 50k dollar vehicles and act like their shit don't stink.

    That being said, Muslims should NOT be allowed in. This isn't the same America of which it once was..sadly. There is NO Vacancy. I'm good with us being us, and them being them and that means 'them' staying in the middle east. Look what the muslims did to Sweden. They're destructive locusts. Not all are bad, but we have a problem in America and it's only making it worse letting everyone in. NO VACANCY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    Anonymous

    Are you paying attention to the problem of Muslim immigration in other countries that were once peaceful? I too believe in equality, but that is being challenged now with the awareness of the chaos that Muslims create anywhere that there has been allowance for them. They are not compatible with peaceful citizenship.

    Pages

    Stay Informed