How the People of Maricopa County Brought Down ‘America’s Toughest Sheriff’

Almost 10 years ago, Manuel de Jesus Ortega Melendres filed a lawsuit in Arizona after being illegally detained by the Maricopa County Sheriff’s Office. Mr. Ortega Melendres was one of many people who dreamed of holding then-Sheriff Joseph M. Arpaio accountable for his reign of terror over Maricopa County, which includes Phoenix and surrounding areas.

A decade later, his dream is a reality.

Arpaio, who held the sheriff’s office for 24 years, stands convicted of criminal contempt of court. The man who declared himself “America’s toughest sheriff” — who racially profiled Latinos and detained people unconstitutionally and in defiance of a federal court order, who tried to hold himself above the Constitution and the rule of law — has ended his career in disgrace, voted out of office and now a convicted criminal.

The story of how Joe Arpaio ended up a convict is the story of how a community rose up to assert people’s rights. It’s also a tale of how a painstaking, sometimes maddeningly slow, legal process ultimately stopped abusive and unconstitutional practices. This story stands as a warning for those government officials in Washington and in state capitals who are now calling for local police agencies to act as immigration enforcers: Don’t be like Joe.

These officials, including President Trump and Gov. Abbott of Texas, should listen carefully to the story of Joe Arpaio. That story begins in the mid-2000s, when he decided to turn the Maricopa County Sheriff’s Office into a full-fledged immigration agency. He jumped to act on anti-Latino constituent “tips” urging him to do something about the Spanish-speaking employees at this restaurant or the Latino day laborers in the parking lot at the hardware store. Rather than explain to these complainants that there was no crime here, Arpaio implemented policies to find and detain undocumented immigrants based on race discrimination and illegal detentions.

Following Arpaio’s direction, deputies of the Maricopa County Sheriff’s Office began to target Latino drivers and passengers in cars and trucks, pulling them over on the pretext of a traffic violation and then questioning them about their immigration status. At first, deputies lurked outside of places like a church in the town of Cave Creek, which ran a day laborer center where workers connected with people who wanted to hire them. Soon Arpaio spread his policies more broadly, running his infamous immigration sweeps by sending up to 100 deputies into a neighborhood — usually a predominantly Latino one — and conducting traffic stops for an entire day or weekend.

Arpaio himself would show up during these sweeps, posing for the press and parading frightened men and women who had been arrested in the traffic stops before the cameras by putting them handcuffed into open-air corrals. During these sweeps, the vast majority of people arrested and detained were never charged with any crime. Instead, they were turned over to Immigrations and Customs Enforcement to decide whether to start deportation proceedings.

But then something extraordinary happened: Community leaders began to fight back.

Arpaio’s immigration policies violated the Constitution in two ways. Deputies were targeting people for traffic stops because of their ethnicity, which violates the Equal Protection Clause of the 14th Amendment. And deputies detained people when there was no reason to believe that they had committed any crime, which violates the Fourth Amendment. People were so frightened of the Maricopa County Sheriff’s Office — the law enforcement officers sworn to protect them — that some avoided leaving the house altogether.

But then something extraordinary happened: Community leaders began to fight back. With tremendous courage, they painstakingly documented the Maricopa County Sheriff’s Office’s civil rights violations, devoting entire weekends to filming traffic stops and days and nights to running volunteer hotlines to field countless desperate calls from people reporting that a family member had been taken by the sheriff’s deputies.

And in 2007, Mr. Ortega Melendres filed a lawsuit seeking to hold Sheriff Arpaio to account after he was arrested during a traffic stop and detained for eight hours, even though he had a valid U.S. visa. In that case, the American Civil Liberties Union, the ACLU of Arizona, the Mexican American Legal Defense and Educational Fund, and the law firm Covington & Burling LLP ultimately won five groundbreaking court rulings in the federal district court and two in the federal appeals court. The first major victory came in December 2011, when the district court issued a preliminary injunction — a legal ruling that Arpaio’s policy of detaining people based solely on suspicion that they were undocumented immigrants violated the Fourth Amendment — and ordered an immediate halt to that practice.

It was this 2011 ruling that ultimately led to Arpaio’s criminal downfall. Even as the Ortega Melendres case continued, Arpaio’s deputies continued to detain people just because of their immigration status in violation of the Constitution and the 2011 court order. In 2016, the federal court ruled that Arpaio was in civil contempt of court for repeatedly violating the 2011 order. This led the U.S. Justice Department’s public integrity unit to bring a separate criminal contempt charge against Arpaio, based on his deliberate decision not to obey the court’s December 2011 order. On July 31, 2017, Arpaio was convicted. His sentencing is set for October 5.

During the civil and criminal contempt trials, Joe Arpaio showed his two faces. On the witness stand, he appeared meek and claimed that he was unaware of what was happening in his own agency. His constant refrain was that he wasn’t responsible for the violations of the court’s order because he delegated the running of the agency to his deputies.

But the other face of Joe Arpaio came through in video recordings of his public statements to the press and his many donors and supporters. This Arpaio boasted that no one would tell him what to do. This Arpaio expressed defiance of the federal district court. This Arpaio ordered a sergeant to detain a group of immigrants without any criminal charge, even after the sergeant protested that it would violate the court order because Arpaio wanted to get to the jail and personally give a TV interview to show off his arrests.

This story did not end well for Arpaio, and each chapter inflicted terrible harms on the people of Maricopa County and civil rights and civil liberties. These are the same harms that will flow from President Trump’s executive order, which seeks to penalize “sanctuary cities,” and Texas’s Senate Bill 4, a draconian and unconstitutional state law that punishes police chiefs and sheriffs who decline to detain people based only on their immigration status. Politicians who are pushing for these backward policies should heed the lesson that Joe Arpaio learned the hard way.

View comments (70)
Read the Terms of Use

Anonymous

The Reign of terror description is a huge exaggeration. This is not the French Revolution where people were being rounded up and beheaded. His criminal downfall is a contempt of court conviction. Not a corruption issue. He enforced immigration laws. The court said he was racially profiling and didn't stop when told. Let's keep it in perspective.

Anonymous

Put pink underwear pink socks on the prick put him one of those prison tents with no fan or AC in Phx in August you disgusting racist

Anonymous

So much for justice. Trump knows nothing about the law and does not care apparently as he pardons Joe today.

waggishwoman007...

these cops are mindless idiots for following such a leader

Anonymous

FK ALL of you. The President has spoken and now Sheriff Joe Arpaio is an innocent man again. LMAO at you worthless libtards.

Anonymous

"Fight for immigrants' rights- Support the ACLU" WTF??? Are you SERIOUS? It's called the AMERICAN civil liberties union. NOT the Immigrants civil liberties union. You're SUPPOSED to be supporting Americans you worthless retards.

James D.

Why don't you focus on rooting out all the drug dealers that come through Arizona and sell those drugs? Why do you not encourage the people of Arizona to help law enforcement by identifying the drug dealers? We ALL know they have an idea who those dudes are!! If they actually helped the authorities they would NOT have been harassed.....think about it.
Oh, I forgot, you actually defend those scumbags!!!

Anonymous

It is good to be an American when justice is finally exacted on those who swear to uphold the law and in fact grievously violate it.
Sheriff Joe is going to be in for a not- so great a surprise when he winds up in detention in a place where police are treated the same as child molesters and it seems all too fair to me.

Anonymous

Rather strange you leave George Soros who was as bad and is as bad as Hitler out of the story ! You all have become an anti-American group that makes money off of desperate refugees you claim to protect - A total conflict of interest. Instead you bring terror and trauma to Americans who have been killed and bombed by the group you want us to give you money for . The scam is transparently clear to patriots we deserve the right to defend our own country in fact.. as parents we have an "animalistic divine duty to defend our offspring at any and all cost" from the evils brought in by refugees and illegal aliens .! And two are dying death that's what we will do it would be nice if an agency named with America in it would be concerned about our liberties not illegals and refugees !! Just like your voter suppression agenda you suppress an American boat with every illegal vote that is cast that's not supporting American civil liberties that's anti-American !

Anonymous

Hopefully he will be sheriff again and can reinstate same tactics he had before magma

Pages

Stay Informed