Why It’s Urgent That Congress Act This Year on the Dream Act

The case of 10-year-old Rosa Maria Hernandez is cruel and shocking, even for a Trump administration that has made the indiscriminate targeting of immigrants a top priority.

Americans were rightfully outraged that a 10-year-old girl with cerebral palsy, who has lived in Texas since she was three months old, was separated from her family after undergoing gallbladder surgery at a Corpus Christi hospital. A phalanx of Customs and Border Protection agents accompanied Rosa Maria’s ambulance from a CBP checkpoint to the hospital, waited outside her room while she recovered from surgery, and then took her away from her family and put her into a detention facility in San Antonio.

While Rosa Maria has finally been reunited with her family, the government should now ensure that no deportation proceedings are filed against Rosa Maria or other young immigrants like her. And all Americans and members of Congress disturbed by the injustice on display in Rosa Maria’s case should intensify efforts to pass the bipartisan Dream Act as soon as possible. The Dream Act would protect not just the 800,000 Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) recipients — but an entire generation of young immigrants who grew up in the U.S. like Rosa Maria. DACA recipients and potential Dream Act beneficiaries are not safe unless Congress steps up and acts now.

The urgency to resolve young immigrants’ status becomes clearer and more pressing every day. Despite President Trump’s false reassurances that Dreamers would have “nothing to worry about,” we are already seeing DACA recipients and other young immigrants facing renewed attacks.

The Trump administration was denying DACA renewal applications even before it announced the end of the program. Take the case of Jessica Colotl, a 28-year-old from Atlanta who has lived in the U.S. since age 11 and graduated with academic distinction from high school and college in Georgia. Twice this year, a federal judge has stepped in to restore Jessica’s wrongfully denied DACA status, which the Trump Administration took away arbitrarily even though the Department of Homeland Security had granted her DACA twice previously and her circumstances remained unchanged.

Or take the case of Jesús Arreola, a 23-year-old resident of the Los Angeles area, who has lived in the U.S. since age one. Jesús worked at the Chateau Marmont in Hollywood, was an Uber and Lyft driver, and is the primary caregiver for his parents and siblings. DHS granted him DACA status in 2012, 2014, and again in 2016. Despite his valid DACA status, federal immigration authorities arrested him in February while he was driving a customer and falsely accused him of human smuggling. Even though an immigration judge promptly rejected the government’s bogus claims, and Jesús was never charged with any crime, DHS revoked his DACA. He is far from the only case of a wrongful DACA revocation, a practice the ACLU is challenging in a class action lawsuit.

Trump also is using administrative measures to hurt thousands of young people. Because of the new DACA reapplication deadline created by the administration, 22,000 DACA recipients will be at risk of deportation. The government did not provide these Dreamers with an official notice of the new and arbitrary Oct. 5, 2017, deadline, and thousands missed it as a result. Unless Congress does its job and passes legislation, 1,400 Dreamers per business day will start to lose their permits to legally live and work at home and become at risk of deportation.

Keep in mind, President Trump’s decision to end DACA was the outcome of a plot created by anti-immigrant leaders, including Attorney General Jeff Sessions, White House Adviser Stephen Miller, and state attorneys general like Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton. There should be no confusing what these hardliners’ ultimate goals are. They want to “prepare for and arrange [DACA recipients’] departure from the United States” and enact policies that terrorize their friends and families.

Congress should not give into the un-American agenda of deporting Dreamers and should instead take immediate action to protect them, along with their friends and families. Congress should attach these protections to must-pass legislation before the holidays, as Sen. Kamala Harris (D-Calif.) and others have been calling for. And any efforts to pass a fix for Dreamers should not be paired with hardline immigration provisions like increased detention and deportation efforts, more CBP and Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents, and the further militarization of border communities.

It’s time that responsible members of Congress from both parties took action on behalf of these young immigrants. No young immigrant Dreamer should have to spend the holidays wondering if they will have to leave the country they call home.

View comments (16)
Read the Terms of Use


record this IP. It’s being unlawfully tracked by the FBI.


So let me get this straight.
People who entered this country ILLEGALLY should be allowed to stay in this country and continue to steal jobs and resources from American citizens.
Does this make sense?

Dr. Joseph Goebbels

It makes sense as long as they are willing to obey the laws and be productive unlike a lot of the local layabouts and dill weeds.


No this is not right and they should get the opportunities people who entered in America or to any state, illegally should be sent back to his/her homeland. If it's not so it's a question mark for authorities and it doesn't make any sense. Would love to read more after my https://www.goldenbustours.com/yosemite-tours/.


Thru history immigrants did make America great. That's because they entered legally, obeyed the law, were hard working, moral, ethical people, that didn't come to destroy America but to join in and become part of her.


Keep any DREAM Act separate from any piece of tax reform or budget spending bill. The DREAM Act has nothing to do with taxation or fiscal policy so that should be passed separately on its own merits...

The only reason Democrats want to slip this bill into any existing piece of legislation is because they know the DREAM Act will fail on its own and need a crutch to get this bill passed, so they attach it to legislation which will be heard before the House and Senate. The fact that people like the author and their cohorts in Congress advocate slipping this into a tax reform bill, spending bill or other unrelated piece of legislation proves that the DREAM Act can't pass on it's own....

Because of the self serving Democrats (along with a terrible candidate), the Midwest went for Trump while the rest of us paid the price with another equally bad choice...

For those who may complain about my post, well this isn't my problem...my parents don't have to worry about Trumps stupid Deportation Machine nor they send tons of people to the US. Your problem isn't necessarily my problem...


If they do attach it to any piece of legislation that US citizens need passed, or a budget, the Democratic Party will be signing its own death warrant. Can you imagine the outrage if school children, veterans, seniors, etc end up being hurt because the Democrats attached the Dream Act to some legislation those groups needed passed?

Dr. Joseph Goebbels

"I'm dreaming of a white Christmas ....": Irving Berlin circa 1942.


I certainly don't want a white Christmas, I'm done with the NorEasters dumping snow. I'd rather deal with cloudy skies or rain...

evelyn thomas

my name is Evelyn from USA, am 40 year of age,i had three miscarriages,this got my husband putting all the blame on me saying i am the problem in his house,this made him not giving me all the attention and also coming home late,though i am a christian i was beginning to loose my hope because there is a saying delay is dangerous,so with this i became confuse and not knowing what to do anymore. so i decided to seek for help on the internet then i came across one DR rahany who i explained my problem to, he told me not to worry that i am in the right place and that he has a herb that is going to help me get pregnant, which he send to me, to his glory i became pregnant again within one week of contacting him, and as i am writing this testimony i have giving birth to my second child, thanks to the man who made me a mother at this age,for those who have pregnancy issue you can contact him (rahanyherbalcenter@yahoo.com).or you can also message him on whats app(+14422433334)


Stay Informed