Elementary School Kids Don’t Belong in Handcuffs

Chrystal McCadden thought she had done everything necessary to ensure an appropriate, safe educational environment for Cameron, her 7-year-old son who has attention deficit hyperactivity disorder. In addition to obtaining appropriate professional services for her son, she also worked with the school district in Flint, Michigan, to develop an individualized education plan, or IEP. Over the course of 13 months, she also met repeatedly with the administrators of an after-school program run by the local chamber of commerce to discuss Cameron’s condition, needs, and strategies for addressing his disability-related challenges. 

Nevertheless, on Oct. 12, 2015, when Cameron allegedly ran across bleachers and kicked a supply cart — conduct consistent with his disability — the afterschool program declined to follow protocols specified by the child’s IEP. Instead, a police officer was summoned. The officer encountered a little boy who was just shy of four feet tall and who weighed about 55 pounds. Cameron was immediately seized and placed in handcuffs. 

When the afterschool program got around to calling Ms. McCadden, the fact that her son was in cuffs was mentioned almost in passing. She disregarded it, believing that the handcuffs must have been toys, part of Halloween activities or a game. When she arrived and learned to her horror that what was done to her son was no game, she vigorously demanded the removal of the restraints. She was then even more alarmed to learn that Cameron could not be released because the officer did not have the key. Almost a full hour passed before the child was finally released. 

On behalf of Cameron, the ACLU of Michigan, the ACLU’s Disability Rights Program, and private cooperating attorneys filed a lawsuit against the Flint Police Department and the Flint Chamber of Commerce. The lawsuit asserts claims for Fourth Amendment and disability law violations. 

In addition to requesting that the court declare Cameron’s handcuffing illegal, order that it never happens again, and award compensation to the McCaddens, the lawsuit and a large coalition of local grassroots community organizations demand the total withdrawal of police officers from Flint’s elementary schools. Against a backdrop of a water crisis that has had a demonstrable physical impact on school children throughout the city, members of the community believe money spent on police in elementary schools would be better spent on professionals who are trained and equipped to deal with the problems of Flint’s children. No one is satisfied with handcuffs as a response. 

Unfortunately, Cameron’s experience was not unique. 

Although students with disabilities are only 12 percent of the national public school student population, they account for 75 percent of students subjected to physical restraint in schools. In addition, while African-American students like Cameron are only 19 percent of students with disabilities, they account for 36 percent of students subjected to mechanical restraints like handcuffs. 

More and more, schools in America are turning mundane disciplinary infractions and behaviors that should be addressed through IEPs or a conversation with a counselor into crimes. With the lawsuit, the McCadden family has said enough is enough. No child deserves to have handcuffs slapped on them, especially when their behavior is an expression of their disability. It’s disturbing that these words even need saying.

View comments (34)
Read the Terms of Use

Anonymous

this is an important issue.

Anonymous

Too many young people, especially young people of color and lower-income backgrounds, make up too much of the prison population all across the country. Law enforcement should never be called to deal with disciplinary situations in which no laws were broken. Laws, not school rules.

Anonymous

The US educational system is broken so badly, that it ends up being the opposite of what it is created for. Those in charge are inputting garbage to their students and receiving garbage in return.

Jim D.

I vote for school choice. My wife worked as a volunteer head of a private Christian School for 22 years. I worked full time and supported her and her efforts. If pubic school as we know it would be absolved and the government - fed & state were to give vouchers to parents for their children's education, the parents could then "spend" the vouchers on oh my home school, private school and faith based, parochial schooling. With competition these issues, hand cuffing a child goes away. If you don't like the fact that the teacher in her exasperation skipped accepted protocol and call resource officer who also overreacted with school choice, pull your kid and go somewhere else, take responsibility for your offspring and oh my teach them yourself.

Clipping Path S...

Thank you so much. Just what I was looking for !!!!

Tommy Shenanigans

Q: How do you turn a pussy into a dick? A: Put a badge on it.

A.F.

In addition to the police department and chamber of commerce, what about the afterschool program itself? Was it sued? Has it been ordered to actually follow its own protocols and not to bring in the police? Has it faced any consequences?

Anonymous

I am sorry but as a person with ADHD who raised a child with ADHD, this child's behavior is not "consistent with the disability." Children with ADHD are compulsive and have a hard time focusing. This doesn't mean they shouldn't be disciplined or do not know how to behave. Sounds more like bipolar to me. I don't agree with putting children in handcuffs but I also don't believe in public schools for children who can not follow simple rules or procedures. What if the kicked cart injured another child? What if he decides to throw things and hits a child in the head. Teachers in a classroom have enough problems without having to deal with uncontrollable children.

Anonymous

Overconsideration of “what ifs” leads down the very slippery slope towards totalitarianism. You have to stick to only what actually happened and not what **could have happened**. Worrying to much about “what if” scenarios will result in you concluding that it is necessary for schools to enforce absolute authoritarian control over students with an endless list of prohbitions and have armed police enforce school rules as de facto laws.

Anonymous

i totally agree. discipline should be child appropriate and not criminalized. it's a form of child abuse.

Pages

Stay Informed