Since When Are Consensual Sexual Relationships a Threat to National Security?

Photo: The Shared Experience/Flickr

Apparently raiding and shutting down a popular male escort service ranks among the priorities of the Department of Homeland Security in its fight for “a safer, more secure America, which is resilient against terrorism and other potential threats.”

It is difficult to fathom how arresting the staff members of and seizing records from, a website that advertised the services of male escorts, including many transmen, helps make America more safe or secure. What we do know is that criminalizing sex work and shutting down services like make the LGBT community less safe.

Whether because LGBT people — particularly those of color, transgender women, and youth — face job discrimination, family rejection, homelessness, and criminalization or because our bodies and desires are at once demonized and exoticized, our community has long-turned to the sex industry for critical means of support and survival. Data from the National Transgender Discrimination Survey, for example, has shown that transgender people engage in sex work at a rate at least 10 times that of cisgender women, and at least 13 percent of transgender people who experience family rejection have done sex work at some point in their lives.

When your body is a site for harassment, your health care is withheld, your ability to walk down the street is criminalized, your identity is called a “social experiment” but you still dare to survive, the sex industry can offer not only an avenue for survival but also for affirmation. And for those who are able to utilize online platforms to meet clients, these platforms provide a safer alternative to street-based work where there is less time to negotiate safety needs and higher risk of violence from both clients and law enforcement.  

So when a platform like is shut down, it not only cuts off a singular source of income and stability for many people in our community, it also takes away vital safety mechanisms for screening clients, sharing information, and controlling one’s labor that individuals rely on to work safely in the sex industry.

As our colleagues from Lambda Legal and the National Center for Transgender Equality explain, “No one’s life has been improved by the raid on Rentboy, and thousands of lives — a great many of them LGBTQ — are ruined by the criminalization of sex work every day.”

We at the ACLU have supported the decriminalization of sex work since 1977. Yet here we are almost 40 years later, and the resources of our federal and state law enforcement agencies are invested in shutting down a website that increased safety and harmed no one.  

In a summer that marked the culmination of the long fight for marriage equality with a victory at the Supreme Court, the raid on is a stark reminder of the urgent fights so many are still waging and have waged since the inception of our modern LGBT rights movement.  

Now more than ever we must not leave behind our community members who are regularly policed and prosecuted; the street-based workers and other sex workers who stood by and for the entire LGBT community fighting for our rights and our freedoms since the uprisings at Stonewall led by queer and trans people of color and long before.

As activist and sex industry professional Hawk Kinkead wrote of our movement’s work in the wake of marriage equality:

“The role of individuals who are either compelled or have chosen the sex industry must be included in LGBT rights conversations as we look to translate the social capital accrued over the last 40 years into tangible cultural changes.” 


View comments (35)
Read the Terms of Use


This is not a LGBT issue at all. This is a prostitution issue. You do realize that prostitution is still illegal, right? I mean, come on ACLU Nationwide, grow up. They were running a prostitution ring... whoops, I mean "escort service" and they got busted. It would have happened (and does regularly happen) when it is women escorts. Stop trying to make this something its not.


You're right, it was a prostitution ring. But why should prostitution be illegal at all? Any sex between consenting adults should be legal. That's a no-brainer.


This is about what is illegal versus what is right and wrong.

If you are a gay man, 40 years ago (oh wait, they are still being discriminated against) it was illegal to be who you truly are.

96 years ago if you were a woman, it was illegal to vote and have the right to consent or refuse consent (oh wait, that still happens in some counties)

The only way you can cling to your attitude is as a cis-gendered-straight-white-male-of-means.

Otherwise check yourself. You'll be next sooner or later


Isn't this a larger issue then? On what intra-personal grounds is prostitution still banned? Isn't ending sex trafficking (which the authorities have claimed was the goal of this raid) easier when you can regulate, tax, protect those involved in the sex industry? Why would you want to sleep with someone whose involvement might be non consensual when you can sleep with someone who honest to god wants to sleep with you?


You'll notice in paragraph seven, a link to this article in which the ACLU calls for the decriminalization of prostitution.


they actually werent running an escort service, so before you start making statements, you should really know what your talking about.


Yes, prostitution is still illegal and this site "crossed" state lines, which would make it something the FBI would normally handle. Why, then, was the Department of Homeland Security involved? The simple answer: LGBT sexuality is always more heavily scrutinized and criminalized than cis-sexuality.


Yes, prostitution is still illegal and this site "crossed" state lines, which would make it something the FBI would normally handle. Why, then, was the Department of Homeland Security involved? The simple answer: LGBT sexuality is always more heavily scrutinized and criminalized than cis-sexuality.


Not everything that is illegal is a target of the Department of Homeland Security. Whether you are for or against the criminalization of sex work, it's clearly not terrorism.


As the piece mentioned, sex work is a queer and trans issue for those at the margins who turn to it to survive because of daily discrimination and violence. The implication of your statement is that the experiences of these queer and trans people, and particularly of many queer and trans people of color, are less important than those of their more privileged counterparts. Why is sex work or homelessness or poverty a queer or trans issue? Because these groups are more vulnerable to these things, particularly when these identities overlaps with other marginalized ones. The challenges faced by queer and trans people always constitute queer and trans issues... Whatever you think is an "LGBT issue" (marriage, I'm guessing) is the result of long push by more elite gay men and women to present it as such, but the reality is that the majority of queer and gender-nonconforming people the world over have other, more dire challenges that impede their sexual, social, and economic freedom as well. These are all valid and real queer and trans issues. It's not up to you to decide whose life and whose struggle "counts."


Stay Informed