The Score on USA Patriot Act

"We've come to love our fears more than we love our freedoms," Rep. Dennis Kucinich (D-Ohio) mused on the House floor just before that chamber voted 315-97 (with 20 members not voting) to reauthorize the USA Patriot Act without any changes for yet another year.

By now, you know the stakes — the tweaks that could have been made to guarantee that Patriot powers are used only against suspected terrorists or spies and to mandate continued reporting to ensure that we actually learn about current and future Patriot abuses. Many of these fixes were, in fact, included in prior iterations of Patriot reauthorization bills introduced in both the House and the Senate.

As Rep. Jane Harman (D-Calif.) pointed out to her colleagues, "I think we are missing an opportunity. There are good ideas in this House about how to curb the abuses with national security letters, how to clarify that roving wiretaps are limited to a single identifiable target, and how to eliminate the lone wolf provision which has never been used and for which existing title III authority can suffice. Those ideas have been the subject of hearings in the Judiciary Committee, but they're not being debated on this floor . . . I think this is a real missed opportunity."

We couldn't agree more. So, in the spirit of the Olympics, here's how the House scored on Patriot Reauthorization for courage, upholding the Constitution, and understanding that we can be both safe and free, on a scale of 1 to 10:

  • Reps. Jerrold Nadler (D-N.Y.), Harman, Kucinich, and Earl Blumenauer (D-Ore.) for speaking on the House floor against a straight reauthorization: 10
  • The 97 members of Congress who voted against a straight reauthorization: 9
  • The 315 members of Congress who voted for a straight reauthorization: 1
  • Reps. Pete Sessions (R-Texas), Dan Lungren (R-Calif.), Lamar Smith (R-Texas), James Sensenbrenner (R-Wisc.), Howard Coble (R-N.C.), Gregg Harper (R-Miss.), and Mac Thornberry (R-Texas) for speaking on the House floor in favor of straight reauthorization: 0

In all seriousness, the ACLU did score the House's vote on the Patriot Act extension, and you can see how your member voted here.


There is one other category of Congresspeople that is worth special mention. Those are the folks who voted for — and spoke in favor of — reauthorization but with the caveat that Congress should use the next year to really examine the effects of the USA Patriot Act and return to it in 2011 ready to make much-needed changes. Now, of course, we'd been telling them to use this past year to do just that. But, we'd like to take Reps. John Conyers (D-Mich.), Silvestre Reyes (D-Texas), and Sheila Jackson-Lee (D-Texas) at their word this time. We'll give them a 4.

Meanwhile, we'll keep the pressure on.

View comments (4)
Read the Terms of Use


aclu sucks


you suck! dont look at the website if you don't like what you see

A Cab Taxi

Why doesn't the ACLU look into the phone tampering. Our calls are interfered with intentionally by federal law enforcement and its a shame how they play games with their authority.


This weak Democratic Adm. doesn't surprise me how it continues to show how it tries to appease the "Moron Majority" in their attempt to "Reach across the aisle". Where is the "Balls" this new Adm. was suppose to "Change things".

Stay Informed