Historic Ruling Puts Justice Within Reach for CIA Torture Victims

Here the Rain Never Finishes

mytubethumb play
Privacy statement. This embed will serve content from youtube-nocookie.com.

CIA torture victims are a big step closer to accountability.

A federal judge has ruled against two CIA contract psychologists, James Mitchell and John Bruce Jessen, in their effort to dismiss a case brought against them on behalf of three victims of the torture program they designed and implemented for the agency.

Senior Judge Justin Quackenbush announced his decision rejecting the psychologists’ motion to dismiss during an argument last Friday in Spokane, Washington. Yesterday, the federal court issued its written opinion.

The ruling is an historic first. Those responsible for the CIA’s torture program never previously had to answer for their actions because no victim’s case has ever proceeded beyond a motion to dismiss. Thanks to this order, we now enter into the pretrial discovery phase of the litigation, an essential step before any trial of Mitchell and Jessen for their key role in the torture of our clients. During discovery our clients will be able to obtain evidence from Mitchell and Jessen to help prove their case at trial — although the Senate torture report already makes public many of Mitchell and Jessen’s actions in the CIA torture program.

The case was brought by Suleiman Abdullah Salim, Mohamed Ben Soud, two survivors of the CIA program, and the family of Gul Rahman, who died as a result of his torture. All three men were subjected to torture techniques and methods that Mitchell and Jessen designed and helped implement for the CIA. To this day, Salim and Ben Soud suffer psychologically and physically from the effects of their torture. Gul Rahman’s family has never been officially notified of his death, and his body never returned to them.

In their effort to evade accountability, lawyers for the two psychologists had argued that the decision to torture the three men was a political one and therefore not appropriate for determination by a judge. They also argued that they are entitled to the same legal immunity as government officials because they were government contractors. 

As the court recognized, however, our judiciary is well equipped to handle claims of torture, and it does not turn a blind eye to prisoner abuse even in wartime. The court pointed out that years of case law “demonstrate the present fallacy of Defendants’ argument that the court must decline jurisdiction because the case falls within the realm of war and foreign policy.”

The court also explained that contractors do not qualify for immunity unless they “merely acted at the direction of the Government” in carrying out lawful government contracts. Mitchell and Jessen went far beyond carrying out orders. They designed, sold, and implemented an unlawful torture program (and earned tens of millions of dollars in the process).

After over a decade of trying, it looks like CIA torture survivors will finally have their day in court.  

View comments (16)
Read the Terms of Use

John Allman

"They also argued that they are entitled to the same legal immunity as government officials because they were government contractors. ... The court also explained that contractors do not qualify for immunity unless they 'merely acted at the direction of the Government' in carrying out lawful government contracts."

It would have been better still if the court had gone as far as to state that not even employees qualify for immunity unless they merely acted at the direction of the Government in carrying out lawful acts of government.


They have some Allah-damned nerve to get ANGRY at what happened to THEM since NONE of them has shown even a MORSEL of regret for what happened to thousands of others, including my daughter's dad (who was burned so effectively out of existence his body was absent at his funeral and we buried an empty coffin.) Did the RAHMEN family bury an empty coffin? Did they burn him out of existence 10 minutes before he knew he was dying? Do they have a tape of all this happening before it did and then had to tell his 15 year old daughter he was never coming home and why? The fact that they don't even fuckin' CARE that it happened makes them not have any gd right to be all ANGRY at anyone else.
That's not even human as far as I'm concerned bc a human being would have a SLIVER of remorse or something that looked like it, especially if they were innocent of doing it and even if they were guilty you'd think they'd feel regret but they have no reaction whatsoever, which feels creepy and strange to someone who spent 16 years with one of the victims of September 11.
Don't talk to me about justice of "people" who thought the Death Penalty by vicious murder was an appropriate response to the crime of greed, which Eric DIDN'T have no matter what bitch Laden said. "Everyone who worked there was greedy with money and deserved to die" he said. Then why isn't Donald Trump dead if everyone who was greedy deserved to die?
I think they're all guilty of the sin of disgusting self-righteous Anger. Thinking they're the only ones who have suffered so they can strut around acting as if they're the only victims.
If that's what takes you to Heaven please drag me to Hell.


this is akin really to taking one for the team. to obfuscate such things as gm receiving a government bailout and now building more than 10% of its vehicles in mexico ( and growing ) so it can pay workers $4.00 an hour.......corporate inversions in order to be shielded to some extent to u.s. taxes and still expect the u.s. military to be their global police force.


Amazing!! Thanks for this valuable post. I am very happy to being a loyal reader of this website.
Getting knowledge from this website only, I started writting on my interest and here I am published four to five articles daily.
Please read this blog and recently I have published few useful article on Android third party apk store. Some of them are,
https://www.apkbc.com/appvn/ Appvn where we can download all latest android games and apps.
https://www.apkbc.com/tutuapp-apk/ Tutuapp to download region locked chinese games and apps for free.
https://www.apkbc.com/blackmart-apk/ Blackmart Apk to download mod games or premium games for free.
https://www.apkbc.com/3ds-emulator/ 3DS Emulator Apk



Here are top android app store where you can download all paid apps for free,




Stay Informed