What President Obama Didn’t Hear or Smell at El Reno

From several years of touring prisons, I’ve learned they all have a distinctive and oddly similar smell: sweat, human misery, and grime — sometimes overlain, but never hidden, by the acrid odors of chlorine and other cleaning products.

The sounds give you a sense of the different parts of the institution. Dorm-style general population units are a constant murmur of activity, with TV programs blending into the sound of people talking, playing cards, microwaving overpriced cups of noodles—anything to pass the idle hours, days, months, and years in custody that lay before them.

I wish he had reached behind a solid steel door to shake the hand of someone in solitary confinement.

Meanwhile, solitary confinement units are filled with the yells of those seeking help, the screams of those battling hallucinations, and the echoing metallic thuds of people banging their hands — or sometimes their heads — against the metal doors of their cells.

But when President Obama visited the El Reno Federal Correctional Institution this week, he did not smell or hear these things.

Everything was clean, quiet, and empty. The president toured a cellblock that had been cleared out — and the floor polished to a spotlessly high sheen — in preparation for his visit. He stepped into an empty cell to see three bunks, neatly folded prisoner uniforms, and a tidy stack of toilet paper rolls.

“Three full-grown men in a 9-by-10 cell,” he mused.

I wish he had seen the parts of the prison that were not cleaned and emptied. I wish he had reached behind a solid steel door to shake the hand of someone in solitary confinement. Seeing these scenes firsthand would have deepened his experience.  

Circumscribed as it was, his visit is still important. It was the first time a sitting president has ever visited a federal prison. And when six carefully selected prisoners were admitted into his protective bubble, he saw the humanity beneath their prison garb. “These are young people who made mistakes that aren't that different from the mistakes I made, and the mistakes that a lot of you guys made,” he told reporters. “That's what strikes me — there but for the grace of God.”

Implicit in that statement is the idea that under different circumstances, these young people could have become reporters like the president’s audience or leaders like the president himself. But instead, the government has determined that they will count down their time in a place that the president’s staff has deemed too dirty, too chaotic for him to see for himself.

So, even with this limited glimpse, President Obama was able to see the enormous waste of human potential that mass incarceration creates. He came away knowing that the 2.3 million people who are in prison and jail every day could be doing something better for themselves and for society.

And that insight is enormously important. We do not have to settle for a criminal justice system that is unproductive, wasteful, and dominated by racial disparities. Bad policies are made, and bad policies can be unmade — it just requires that those in power take a look, as President Obama did, and commit themselves to building something better.

View comments (20)
Read the Terms of Use


I praise President Obama for his courageous efforts to even attempt justice reform. Perhaps he could do a sporadic visit particularly on a U.S.P. where my family member is serving a LIFE sentence plus 40 years for a non-violent offense and experience what was mentioned in the article. He would clearly understand the urgence of transforming our justice system then!!


What did your family member do?


I wish Obama had addressed the national problem of privatized prisons. Decades of draconian, unfair laws came about from lobbying by the powerful corporate prison industry. What kind of country undergirds their justice system by profiteering from overfilled prison cells?


It is so sad how we have completely given up the humane concept of rehabilitation & I have turned to hate & vengence.


I agree. Incarceration for profit is immoral in my opinion. We launder billions of taxpayer dollars into corporate coffers. I have a family member who was scheduled for knee surgery by the Veterans Administration before he was incarcerated. Now the screws from previous surgery are "backing out" and the fluid on his knee is almost softball size yet no one cares. He's on a list to be seen and that has been the case for over a year. What Obama saw was nothing like a state prison run by corporations. No jobs, no school, no dental and this is what passes for medical. There is a lot of lip service but no one really cares.


Too bad the truth of the conditions were covered.


oh good lord - do you think the president EVER walks into some place that the floor is dirty, assuming they knew he was coming? Just be grateful for today -- that we have the first president ever visiting such a facility.


Wish he could have spent an overnight in a cell. Wish everyone could. Empathy is so lacking.


Wish he could have spent an overnight in a cell. Wish everyone could. Empathy is so lacking.

Keith Rutherford

And half of them are probably in jail because of the judges liberal use of "Contempt of Court" for anything they feel they can get away with just to incarcerate some one. What a waste of money and life.


Stay Informed