Black Lives Matter Is Still Here — And Avoiding the Mistakes of Their Predecessors

This piece originally appeared at Newsweek

The fifth anniversary of the founding of Black Lives Matter makes me think back 50 years, not five. Shortly before he was killed, Martin Luther King lamented that the gains of the civil rights movement had come at “bargain rates” because it cost America nothing to integrate lunch counters and buses or give Blacks the right to vote.

King knew that the real fight — against systemic forces such as the criminalization of African-Americans — lay ahead. As a 10-year-old growing up in Memphis, Tennessee, I did not understand — I just saw what looked like visible progress until King was killed, and it seemed like the progress not only stopped, it rolled back. 

The young activist started at 26 and was dead at 39. Richard Nixon’s nefariously designed “war on drugs” came next, fueling the over-policing and mass incarceration of Black bodies. Fifty years later, we are in the middle of another attempt to reckon with our national failure to achieve real and sustainable progress toward racial justice.

Five years ago, a group coalesced around the leadership of Patrisse Khan–Cullors, Alicia Garza, and Opal Tometi, and Black Lives Matter came into being. National awareness of issues around policing in America has grown significantly since then because BLM and other community-based organizations are forcing America to take a clear look at what we are really doing in the name of “policing” in Black and brown communities.

Their public actions are visible. They were leaders in making sure that America knew the names Trayvon Martin, Tamir Rice, Tanisha Anderson, Mya Hall, Walter Scott, Sandra Bland. They have disrupted our everyday lives by making us focus on the everyday lives of people who live with policing based on pro-active racial profiling.

They have led in redefining leadership of community-based movements by recognizing and addressing gaps in movement spaces and leadership for women, queer, and transgender people and those who have moved the work forward in the background with little or no recognition.

This has given the movement brilliant leaders and strategists. It is one of the foundations of sustainable community-based power. Some of their work is visible, some is not. After many Americans were shocked by the video of a police officer throwing a girl from her desk in a South Carolina classroom, the ACLU wanted to expand its work fighting the school-to-prison pipeline by challenging a South Carolina law that made it a crime to “disturb schools.”

This law was used to charge a girl in the classroom with a crime for simply standing up and demanding that the officer stop physically abusing her classmate. The ACLU was interested in litigation challenging provisions of this law. BLM activists put us in contact with the young woman who was physically abused by the officer. They set up a community meeting on a Sunday where community members came to talk about what was happening to their children in school.

The people who came to share their stories included the family of our client in the lawsuit, Niya Kenny. BLM activists helped connect the legal challenge to sustained organizing in the community and provided mentorship and support for our client and the young woman assaulted by the officer.

As a result of the ACLU lawsuit, the state of South Carolina repealed the challenged provisions of the law. No child in South Carolina will be charged with a crime for “disturbing” their classroom. Niya Kenny has drawn on the courage she showed in her classroom to continue fighting to make a difference in the community. She is now working with the same BLM activist who organized that first meeting, advocating for Black girls and encouraging their leadership.

The lawsuit and victory for South Carolina’s children would not have happened in this way without BLM. Today, we continue the fight for racial justice — whether challenging racist stop-and-frisk laws or elevating the stories of Black and brown people targeted by 911 vigilantes — and remain inspired by BLM’s work.

As I look back, I see similarities between the civil rights movement 50 years ago and BLM today. At both points in history, the leadership was intelligent, charismatic, and powerful, but today there is an emphasis on a much broader base of leadership. BLM’s decentralized movement goes far beyond the impact of a few major leaders — and that is the way Ms. Khan-Cullors, Ms. Garza and Ms. Tometi planned it.

Constrained by the prevailing social mores of the larger society, the movement of the mid-20th century kept too many on the margins. Take for example the treatment of Black queer activists like Bayard Rustin, who was the mastermind behind King’s March on Washington but, due to homophobia, was relegated to obscurity. Likewise, visionary Black women like the legal scholar Pauli Murray battled misogyny within the movement that couldn’t have existed without them.

Today, there is much to learn from the way that BLM has pushed past mere discussions about diversity and inclusion to take concrete action on these principles internally and in their work. Learning from the shortfalls of the '50s and early '60s, BLM activists are keenly alert to “bargain basement” gains and politics of respectability that won’t address core issues of racism in America.

Five years is but a minute in the fight for racial justice, but with BLM’s still unfolding narrative, I’m already compelled to stay for the whole movie — it looks like it could be special.

View comments (7)
Read the Terms of Use

Dr. Timothy Leary

I am going to start my own organization: the GBM, Good Behavior Matters.


I think in the last 50 years we have made good progress as a whole, but we still have a ways to go. However, maybe BLM should be protesting the fact that 66% of black children have single parent families because of fathers leaving.... There is a ridiculously strong correlation between this number and income, educational attainment, and crime. Again not saying there is zero prejudice out there, but IMHO more emphasis needs to be in the mirror and not at everyone else.


Speaking of 50 years, your facts seem to come from back then. It has long been disproved that this is a major impactful issue in black households. Access to education, housing, jobs and targeting by police are MUCH more of a factor. And surprisingly (to some), BLM and organizations like it address those very issues.


I agree with mist of what you said, but must point out that the civil rights heroes of the 50’s and 60’s were friends with the Jews, who tremendously supported their work and stood beside them throughout. BLM has taken an unnecessary hostile position on Israel in its mission. The singling out of one tiny struggling country to the exclusion of other grotesque human rights abusers and abusers of black and brown people worldwide creates a gratuitously nasty BLM platform plank that drove away natural and historic allies, and had no positive impact, nor did it advance the mission of BLM in any discernible way. I support BLM and it’s incredibly important work, but cannot wholeheartedly sign onto such a mission statement. If BLMfeeks the need to codify support for all the oppressed, then codify who all the oppressed are. Singling out Israel for special treatment is anti-Semitic.

By the way, Mr. Robinson, your keynote at the Equal Justice Conference remains one of the best addresses I have ever seen, bar none. It is a model of public persuasive speaking. I have watched it countless times since you gave it. Thank you!


Why should cops give a shit about black lives?
You people kill each other way more effectively.
There is no grand conspiracy black American culture is just a failure.
The only ones who escape and succeed do so by emulating white Western culture is. American culture. Our schools our clothes our venacular the only way y'all ever snuck a halfrican into the white house was his absolute vanillaness
If you people are to ever succeed assimilation must he total get married raise your kids for once, and for God's sake get jobs




Clowns that dont matter

Stay Informed