South Carolina Legislature Repeals Racist ‘Disturbing School’ Law for Students

In 2015, video surfaced of a police officer violently dragging a Black girl from her school desk. He was arresting her, and using shockingly excessive force, because she was “disturbing school,” a vague law that more or less made it a crime for a student to be loud, to talk back to staff or school police. In other words, it criminalized being a kid. 

Unsurprisingly, this law has disproportionately affected students of color, who are already over-policed outside the school walls, so we sued in August 2016. Last week, we scored a victory on behalf of all students who have been pulled into the maze of the state’s criminal justice system.

On Thursday, South Carolina Gov. Henry McMaster signed an amendment repealing the crime of disturbing schools for students in the state of South Carolina. The importance of this law being signed cannot be understated. Its passage will eliminate a major source of the school-to-prison pipeline, which has caused grievous and lifelong harm to students across South Carolina. 

In addition to the immediate harms of being arrested and subjected to the criminal justice system, students are also subject to more severe discipline that can include expulsion or assignment to alternative programs that fail to provide a pathway to graduation. Stigma and further disconnect from school are also likely to follow, increasingly jeopardizing school success. And a criminal record alone can close the door to employment, college, and housing opportunities. 

When we filed our lawsuit, thousands of youth were arrested each year for things like talking to another student after being sent out of class, cursing in the lunchroom, and even for speaking out against police misconduct.  The vague terms of the law, which criminalized youth considered disturbing or obnoxious at school, also allowed for disparate and discriminatory enforcement. 

Our review found that across the state, Black youth were nearly four times as likely as their white classmates to be deemed criminally disturbing school. In Charleston, Black youth were a staggering six times more likely to be charged with the offense, and disturbing school was the number one reason youth entered the juvenile justice system. 

Sadly yet unsurprisingly, the circumstances in South Carolina are consistent with those found in many other jurisdictions. Across the country, Black youth and students of color, as well as students with disabilities, are more likely to be disciplined and arrested in school. Our culture of mass punishment that starts in schools is partly to blame. The law’s wording itself is also partly to blame. Disparities are more likely to be found when an offense is defined using subjective terms, allowing implicit bias to creep in and be weaponized by the Orwellian-named “school resource officers,” who are nothing more than cops in school. 

In South Carolina and elsewhere, the impacts are devastating for youth. For example, when children are pushed into the juvenile justice system from school, they are less likely to graduate and more likely to have future involvement with the criminal justice system. Fortunately, research on adolescent development has led to the creation of many school-based approaches to youth behavior that are more effective for both schools and children. 

In the year after we filed our lawsuit, the Department of Juvenile Justice reported a sharp decline in disturbing schools arrests. Schools, police, and communities were beginning to change their approach to school children.  The repeal of the disturbing schools crime for students is a further substantial step in the right direction for South Carolina’s students. We will continue to fight to ensure that no young person is treated as a criminal simply for being a child. No child’s education should be disturbed by racist and backward, and now illegal, “disturbing schools” laws anywhere in this country. 

View comments (45)
Read the Terms of Use

Anonymous

Just because she doesn't want 2 behave and act normal in school isn't cause 2 make her a hero, like your paper is doing. U r legitimizing her unruly actons by denigrating the officer. Don't give credence 2 bad behavior

Anonymous

ACLU is useless

Dr. Timothy Leary

You are useless. You are as useless as tits on a boar hog.

Anonymous

This tactic worked real well in case of the Florida school shooter eh?

Anonymous

Part of the problem in the education system is the low expectations placed on high school students. They are young adults, not children. They should be expected to act like young adults.

South Carolinian Rob

Look, I'm not sure arresting a student for talking or similar is a good idea so I'm fine with this. But I've been witness to students, white and black, that blatantly disregard any authority of the teacher. This effects not only that students schooling but the entire class. So now, there basically is no recourse. Teachers call authorities in the first place when they realize their authority is moot. But now it seems they just have to let it happen and disrupt the class. I'm not sure if it's the same incident, but I remember seeing where a police in uniform was trying to get the young lady to come with him and she grabbed a hold of her desk and resisted. What are they supposed to do at that point? Because talking doesn't work. It's not a racist rule either. Racism has nothing to do with it. Are all laws against murder racist because the percentage of black criminals incarcerated is much higher than white? Perhaps there's a bigger issue.

Anonymous

Things wont change as long as you enable these spoiled kids. Black youth are targeted mire because they cause all the trouble. Everyone knows it but are afraid of being cslled racist do they keep quiet. Watch now as the schools will turn into crsp holes.

Anonymous

You state that minorities were more likely to be charged. Did you investigate if they were more likely to cause disturbances?

Tired Teacher

The law may have been enforced poorly, but SOMETHING is needed to improve the environment of schools. Ask any teacher, particulrly middle and high school teachers. Some students are out of control. Teachers and administrators are powerless to offer a quality education to the vast majority of students who want to fo the right thing.

Anonymous

Haven't you figured it out - everyone can just blame the teachers. We aren't engaging, motivating, understanding, relating or differentiating your lesson plans. :)

Pages

Stay Informed