The House’s Obamacare Repeal Bill Would 'Defund' Planned Parenthood. Here’s The Truth About What That Means.

This week, the House will mark up a bill that would decimate the Affordable Care Act and could leave millions of Americans uninsured. As if that weren’t destructive enough, it also contains language that would “defund” Planned Parenthood health centers. Taken together, these two actions would devastate access to health care generally, and reproductive health care in particular.

The way some anti-choice members of Congress talk about it, you’d think that there’s a line item for Planned Parenthood in the federal budget every year. But that's not true. In fact, Planned Parenthood health centers operate like any other health care provider: They serve patients and are reimbursed by insurance companies for the care that they provide. Because Planned Parenthood is a key safety-net provider serving many low-income women, men, and young people, many of the patients they serve are insured through the federal Medicaid program.

So what would it actually mean to “defund” Planned Parenthood?

The reality is that Congress is considering legislation that would block patients who qualify for Medicaid from going to Planned Parenthood health centers. That’s right — this bill specifically targets low-income patients by prohibiting them from accessing services like birth control, cancer screenings, and sexually transmitted infection testing and treatment at the Planned Parenthood health centers they trust. Seventy-five percent of Planned Parenthood’s patients have incomes at or below 150 percent of the federal poverty level — just $12,060 for an individual — and more than half of Planned Parenthood’s 650 health centers are located in rural or medically underserved areas.

We know what this is really about. Anti-choice members of Congress want to restrict access to abortion in any way they can. They want to punish Planned Parenthood for providing safe, legal abortion services and are even telling angry constituents at home that they want to defund Planned Parenthood to stop taxpayer funding of abortion.

But there’s a pretty big problem with that: It doesn't work that way.

Federal dollars can’t be used to pay for abortions — except in very limited circumstances — as a result of the Hyde Amendment. This is a harmful, discriminatory policy that should be eliminated, and pro-choice champions in Congress have introduced a bill to do just that. Nevertheless, Hyde remains in place for now, so the claim that defunding Planned Parenthood would stop taxpayers from funding abortion is a hollow one.

The truth is anti-choice Members of Congress want to force Planned Parenthood health centers to close their doors — even if it means closing the doors on millions of low-income people who rely on Planned Parenthood for cervical cancer screenings, tests and treatment for HIV and other STIs, and birth control. These lifesaving preventive services make up the vast majority of what Planned Parenthood does.

And while Planned Parenthood’s opponents claim that patients can just go elsewhere, the fact is that other providers simply cannot fill the void that would be left in many communities if Planned Parenthood health centers close. We’ve seen how this plays out at the state level.

We know what this is really about. Anti-choice members of Congress want to restrict access to abortion in any way they can.

When Texas cut family planning funding in 2011 in an attempt to defund Planned Parenthood, the results were disastrous for women in the state. Last month, a Texas court blocked the state from cutting off Medicaid reimbursements to Planned Parenthood, which would have limited patient options even further. And it’s not just Texas. States across the country have attempted to block patient access to Planned Parenthood health centers, including in Florida, Missouri, and Iowa.

We can’t let this happen nationwide.

So the next time you hear Congress talk about “defunding” Planned Parenthood, you’ll know the truth: that they want to cut off access to the affordable, high-quality care that Planned Parenthood provides to over 2 million people every year.

And if you stand with the millions who rely on that care, call your senators and representative and let them know you’ll hold them accountable for their vote.

View comments (44)
Read the Terms of Use

AS

Just started reading the new healthcare law proposal, but I don't think it goes after Planned Parenthood by name. I suspect that what is actually being "defunded" is the ability of women who rely on the Medicaid expansion to pay for reproductive health treatment/care unless they switch to a doctor's office that does not perform abortions. I think it's going to refund patients at certain income levels- not defund specific services. Like I said though, I'm still trying to read it and figure it out.

In Massachusetts, I believe the governor has suggested that the state will find substitute funding to make sure people can continue to pick who provides their healthcare though.

Anonymous

here is the deal when you cry "DEFUND PLANNED PARENTHOOD"you're actually defunding:::
pap smears, breast exams, flu vaccines, cancer screenings, access to safe effective birth control, cholesterol testing, STscreenings, diabetes screenings, UT screenings, eretile dysfunction, treatment for yeast infections, STD treatment, mammograms, physicals, prenatal services, UTI treatment, mental health care, referral services, tetnus vaccines, thyroid screenings, anemia testing

Anonymous

These services, except abortions, are availble through medicare medicaid at other clinics besides pp clinics.

Anonymous

"These services, except abortions, are availble through medicare medicaid at other clinics besides pp clinics."

Yeah, but good luck getting an appointment in a timely manner. Other clinics do offer similar services, but odds are high you will have to wait weeks to months to get in, especially with medicare/medicaid, which in a lot of cases is not an option.

Anonymous

These services are provided at other clinics? As a private healthcare patient, no other hospital or center could offer me a simple pregnancy test. The ones that could wouldn't accept my insurance. The only option I had was planned Parenthood. So please tell me again that we don't need planned Parenthood? I live in one of the biggest cities in California, it shouldn't be that hard for me, but it is.

Anonymous

If these people have Medicaid medicare they can go to pp to get everything but an abortion. I don't want the taxes I pay going to pay for abortions which violate the civil liberties of the MOST vulnerable defenseless sector of Americans...the unborn. If pp provides contraception, there should be no need for pp abortions.

Anonymous

Birth control is not 100% and doesn't help in cases of rape. And for women to get exemptions for rape in other countries that only allow rape caused pregnancies to be aborted, they have to prove they were raped. Also women medical disorders that endanger her to be pregnant would need an abortion of birth control fails, which it does.

Anonymous

The worst part about this bill is even rape victims are at a loss. By the language of the bill, rape is now a pre-existing condition.

Anonymous

Pp isn't the only clinic medicare medicaid covers. Your claim of the services has been proved lies in a host of cases. No mri for nonabortion patients, digusting conditions of many clinics, abortion instead of birth control, no counseling on abortion alternatives. Are you saying that only pp provides the services not related to abortion to medicaid medicare patients. You are a prime example of defrauding the govt and you lie when you say bill is taking away coverage for services OTHER THAN abortion.

Anonymous

That's wrong. Almost every planned parenthood in my state doesn't have abortion services but they want to defund them anyways.

Pages

Stay Informed