Scott Lloyd’s Anti-Abortion Ideology Is Harming the People His Agency Is Supposed to Protect

In March 2017, President Trump appointed Scott Lloyd to run a federal agency called the Office of Refugee Resettlement. Lloyd has almost no background in helping refugees. Instead, his main qualification for the job is that he spent his legal career furthering his anti-abortion ideology based on his religious beliefs.

So it should have been no surprise that when Lloyd took office he began imposing his religious views about abortion on the marginalized population that he is supposed help. That population includes unaccompanied immigrant minors. These are young people who come to the United States without their parents, often fleeing unspeakable abuse or torture in their home countries. Many experience sexual assault as they make the journey. Our government is legally obligated to care for these young people while they await reunification with family in the U.S., seek asylum, or are deported. That care includes access to medical treatment.

Privacy statement. This embed will serve content from

But the only way a pregnant minor in ORR custody can obtain access to an abortion, or even objective counseling about her options, is if Lloyd himself personally approves the abortion request. But as Lloyd told me when I deposed him recently, he believes that “abortion is the destruction of human life,” and has never approved an abortion request. He even denied an abortion request from a young woman who had been raped and said she would rather kill herself than carry her pregnancy to term. In fact, Lloyd believes that he has the power to override a young woman’s decision to have an abortion. He also said that he believes that immigrant minors have no constitutional right to abortion.

So instead of providing access to abortion, as required by the law, Lloyd subjects minors to various coercion tactics to try to force them to carry their pregnancy to term. This includes demanding that minors go to so-called “crisis pregnancy centers” from a list “approved” by ORR. Those lists were developed by two anti-abortion entities, CareNet and Heartbeat International. These are anti-abortion, religiously affiliated centers, with the sole purpose of discouraging women from obtaining abortion. One young woman, Jane Doe, who challenged ORR’s policy in court, said staff at the center “prayed for her.” Ms. Doe, and others like her, were forced to have medically unnecessary ultrasounds because of Lloyd’s policy.

Lloyd also forces minors, or the government-contracted shelter where the minor resides, to tell her parents in her home country about the pregnancy and her abortion decision, even where the minor objects and even where doing so would be dangerous for her or other family members.

Lloyd has also gone so far as to personally speak with at least one pregnant minor who was considering abortion to talk with her about her “options.” When these coercion attempts fail, and the minor persists in asking for an abortion, Lloyd simply orders the shelter not to allow her to travel to a clinic.

Lloyd has wreaked havoc on young women’s lives. The young women we represent – the “Janes” – were able to have abortions only after waging legal challenges. But by that time, Lloyd’s policy pushed them further into their pregnancy. For example, Jane Doe was held hostage for four weeks, and was forced to remain pregnant against her will until she finally obtained a court order.

In another particularly egregious situation, Lloyd attempted to intervene after a woman began the process of getting a medication abortion. After she took the first of two pills, demanded that she be taken to an emergency room to assess whether the pregnancy could be continued, including forcing her to have an unnecessary ultrasound. ORR even considered trying to “reverse” the medication abortion through an untested medical protocol against the young woman’s wishes to “save the life of the baby.”

The ACLU has been successful on behalf of the individual Janes so far, but the battle is far from over. There are hundreds of pregnant young women in ORR’s custody each year and Lloyd is still applying his policy to them. We will do everything we can to strike it down to prevent Lloyd from inflicting further harm on marginalized young women.

View comments (33)
Read the Terms of Use

Kathie Wilson

The ability to conceive, gestate, and bear children in NO WAY confers the prerogative to make reproductive decisions for another. Only the person who is pregnant has the right to make decisions about her own pregnancy. Period.

Kathie Wilson

The ability to conceive, gestate, and bear children in NO WAY confers the prerogative to make reproductive decisions for another. Only the person who is pregnant has the right to make decisions about her own pregnancy. Period.


This man is a monster


Scott Lloyd apparently has no heart or compassion, nor is he the least bit interested in carrying out the official obligations of his office. As Head of the Office of Refugee Resettlement, it is his legal responsibility to resettle these refugees and to allow them access to needed care, including abortion. Yet he chooses to deny these young women, some of them minors, access to abortion - solely based on his religious beliefs and anti-abortion views. The law requires him to provide these women access to abortion, and he has no right to block this access. He is not fit to hold this office. Nor is he entitled to call himself a Christian. Good for Ms. Amiri and the ACLU for litigating this issue and standing up for these vulnerable women. The law is their side, and I hope they will prevail in court over Mr. Lloyd.


This man is putting the lives of the young women in jeopardy. How many of the young. Ladies that are pregnant has he killed by not letting them get the healthcare they need. This is an issue of the death of a person so I assume it is okay for him to murder young women who are in need of healthcare and he is denying them care. So the question who is killing who? This man is a lawyer not a doctor he needs to get his M.D. before he makes any medical decisions for any person. He is forgetting we are not suppose to mix church and state just as lawyers shouldnt make medical decisions he should be held liable for every death he is involved with any death at all


What I find so hypocritical about this whole abortion debate, especially from people like Lloyd, is that they don't want to allow the woman/girl to make her own decision about her health or about her own body. And it doesn't matter to them if it endanger/kills these women as long as they have that baby. BUT, and it's a big BUT. They don't want to take care of that baby once it passes through the birth canal and pops into this cold world. They couldn't care less if that baby has 2 heads. 3 legs, 4 arms, a vagina, and 16 penises all determined by prenatal testing,. Or if her family lives in Antartica, and Brazil or if the father lives in Atlantis just as long as the woman has THAT baby. Wonder how many children Lloyd is supporting due to his anti abortion beliefs?


I have read that he paid for an abortion for a girlfriend


How many republicans says all that crap and if it wasn’t their wives getting one they were helping young people /daughters, Trumps paid 4 plenty Legally or not


He probably has an adoption service in his family...


But he believes the rapists should get visitation unless he sighn his rights away, WHAT RIGHTS & the poor girl has to leave him with her living nightmare to do who knows what?


Stay Informed