Hospital Refuses Pregnancy-Related Care Again Because of Religious Directives

Today we filed a lawsuit challenging Dignity Health’s use of religious directives to deny basic reproductive health care to its patients. Filed on behalf of patient Rebecca Chamorro and Physicians for Reproductive Health, the suit argues that withholding pregnancy-related care for reasons other than medical considerations is illegal in California.

Rebecca lives in Redding and is a patient at Dignity Health’s Mercy Medical Center, the only hospital in Redding with a labor and delivery ward. She decided with her doctor that she would get a tubal ligation (otherwise known as getting your tubes tied) during her scheduled C-section in late January. But the hospital refused her doctor’s request to perform the procedure, citing religious directives written by the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops that classify sterilization procedures as  “intrinsically evil.” For Rebecca, there are no hospitals within a 70-mile radius that have birthing facilities and do not follow these directives.

The refusal of hospitals to allow doctors to perform basic health procedures based solely on religious doctrine presents a real threat to a woman’s ability to access health care. Patients seeking medical care from public institutions should not have to worry that religious doctrine rather than medical judgment will dictate what care they receive.

In addition to the lawsuit, we're also filing an emergency motion asking the court to prevent Dignity Health from using the religious directives to interfere with Rebecca's care so that her doctor can perform the procedure during her scheduled delivery in January. A hearing on this motion is scheduled for Jan. 5 at 11 am in San Francisco Superior Court.

Tubal ligation, known familiarly as “getting one’s tubes tied,” is the contraceptive method of choice for more than 30 percent of U.S. married women of reproductive age. An estimated 600,000 women undergo this procedure each year. For women who want a tubal ligation, performing it immediately following delivery (or postpartum) is best practice and aligns with medical standards of care.

In August, we sent a demand letter on behalf of Rachel Miller, another Redding woman who decided with her doctor to have a tubal ligation following the C-section birth of her second child. Under the threat of a lawsuit, the hospital allowed Miller to have the procedure.

A similar demand letter was sent Dec. 2 on behalf of Rebecca, but Dignity Health has to date refused to authorize her doctor to perform the tubal ligation.  

Dignity Health is the 5th largest healthcare system in the country and the largest hospital provider in California, with 29 hospitals across the state. Ten of the 25 largest hospital systems in the U.S. are Catholic-sponsored, and nearly one of nine hospital beds in the country is in a Catholic facility.

View comments (15)
Read the Terms of Use


The ACLU is evil and corrupt in this. A religious organization has the right to follow its religious beliefs and practices. If you seek service from a religious institution, you should expect to follow their beliefs or find service elsewhere. Americans have the right to freedom from religious persecution, which is what the ACLU is doing here. The ACLU is against civil liberties, not supportive thereof, and it is nauseating!

John Stuart Mill

If bad old secular Medicare, Medicaid and insurance money is used to support a hospital, they should not be allowed to infringe on the religious beliefs of their patients. It's not like she can just walk across the street to a different hospital.


Go get em

Jane Grey

I swear sometimes I think I'm living in the 19th century!


It should be illegal for religious organizations to have any role in dictating the standards of care, practices, and information available within medical facilities. I don't care whether it's "crisis pregnancy centers" or hospitals.


Why should a catholic hospital be catholic? Love you asshole liberals. Keep persecuting those doing better for the world than you. You are just like the stinking president suing little nuns. You are anti-religious haters and bigots. I hope you reap what you sow.


i get in a car accident. there is only one hospital for 700 miles. its Mormon. i need a blood transfusion, that is against their religion. i bleed out in a hospital because of it. religious freedom!


She should have gone to a different hospital. It's a Catholic hospital lady you should have known better.

John Stuart Mill

Let's prohibit any Medicare or Medicaid money from going to Catholic hospitals. How long would they stand? They are using secular money from the U.S. taxpayers to dominate and control a health-care market and force their religion on taxpaying Americans. Not good.


Those with religion need to stay the heck out of women's reproductive health, because of religious beliefs, many states have cut off planned parenthood and sex ed in school. Well they will eventually learn that teen pregnancy will be higher than ever just because it's nearly impossible to get birth control, and that many woman are going to die from cervical cancer because they don't have access to planned parenthood to get screenings done to detect the cancer.
This is why religious people piss me off.


Stay Informed