A Wisconsin School District Shrugged After High School Coaches Body-Shamed Cheerleaders

The cheerleaders at Tremper High School in Kenosha, Wisconsin, looked forward to the annual spring banquet as a time to celebrate their hard work in the company of over 100 friends and family members. What they never expected was for the banquet to become a humiliating exercise in body shaming.

In the banquet hall of a Kenosha restaurant in March 2018, the cheer coaches presented some squad members with “most improved” and “hardest worker” awards as the crowd applauded and snapped photos. Yet not all of the awards celebrated the cheerleaders’ hard work and athleticism.

The coaches also presented awards to the cheerleader with the largest buttocks and the largest breasts as well as an award for being the thinnest cheerleader. In video footage obtained by the ACLU, the coaches proclaimed, “We love her butt. Everybody loves her butt” as the recipient of the largest buttocks award made her way to the front of the crowded room.

These three young women were not the first to receive objectifying awards. The largest breasts and buttocks awards were also handed out during the 2017 cheer banquet. Additionally, a cheerleader with brown hair received a blonde wig as an award because she was deemed a “ditzy girl.”

After the 2018 banquet, concerned parents and a coach of another team complained to the Tremper principal and the Kenosha Unified School District (KUSD) leadership. The coach emailed the principal, “I feel that I need to tell you this for the protection of these girls . . . . I don’t think it takes much to see that this is extremely degrading to women.”

She also directly contacted the lead cheer coach to discourage her from objectifying squad members. The cheer coach responded, “I honestly don’t feel that I need to explain myself about how we ran our banquet. Actually we have ran it this way for years and have never had a problem.”

An ACLU client, the mother of a cheerleader and an attendee of the banquet, followed up persistently with the school and KUSD leadership about her concern that the cheer awards sent a harmful message to her daughter and other cheerleaders. Administrators repeatedly brushed her concerns aside, insisting that the awards were just a joke.

Yet a memo the ACLU received through an open records request reveals that a KUSD human resources official tasked with investigating the complaints did not share the leadership’s cavalier attitude. After interviewing the head cheer coach about the incident, she instructed the coach to submit her resignation. The principal rejected the official’s recommendation and told the coach that “she was welcome back” the following year. The coach is still leading the cheerleading team to this day.

Unfortunately, the cheerleading awards are not an isolated incident. They are part of a broader culture of body shaming, victim blaming, and harassment throughout KUSD.

Last year, KUSD students took aim at the district’s sexist dress code, which unfairly targeted female students by banning styles of clothing that they disproportionately wear such as leggings, yoga pants, and tank tops. The school board eventually bowed to student and community pressure by amending the dress code after female students testified about how teachers who enforced the dress code degraded them in front of their peers and forced them to miss out on classroom time.

Most recently, in December 2018, students at Bradford High School in KUSD were instructed to watch a movie as a part of their health curriculum in which a college freshman, Melissa, is drugged and raped by a fraternity brother. The students were then told to fill out a worksheet that asked, “What could have Melissa done differently to have avoided her sexual assault (provide at least 4 examples)?” This question squarely places the blame for a sexual assault on the female victim, rather than the male perpetrator who drugged and raped her.

On Tuesday, the ACLU sent a letter to KUSD raising concerns about the troubling pattern of victim-blaming and body shaming that these incidents represent. We argue that the district’s failure to respond appropriately violates federal and state laws that prohibit sex discrimination, including Title IX. That groundbreaking civil rights law, passed in 1972, requires schools to respond appropriately to incidents of gender-based violence and harassment and prohibits school officials from treating female students as sexual objects or blaming them for the harassment they face. Wisconsin’s Pupil Nondiscrimination Law contains similar prohibitions against sex discrimination.

Far too often, school districts look the other way when students file complaints regarding sexually degrading treatment. Yet if adolescents are taught that body shaming and harassment are acceptable, they will carry these messages with them for the rest of their lives. And if schools teach students that victims of gender-based violence are even partly at fault, how will we ever eradicate the workplace sexual harassment that the #MeToo movement has proven is rampant throughout the country?

That is why the ACLU is demanding mandatory anti-harassment training for all KUSD employees, including teachers and coaches, and that the district take immediate steps to reform its health curriculum to eliminate victim-blaming. Public educators who objectify female students’ bodies are not only conditioning girls and young women to normalize sexual harassment — they are also violating the law. We hope KUSD will step up and send the message loud and clear to its students, faculty, and staff that harassment and body shaming are no laughing matter.

View comments (68)
Read the Terms of Use

SU Hall

This is absurd! THIS is the very reason why women are treated like second class citizens! Having anyone point out a woman's body with ridicule is disgusting at any level - high school or anywhere!
Thing is, an award for the biggest 'dick' would be a feather in that guy's cap!
So, on one hand, women being body-shamed. On the other, men wanting to be praised for their manhood!
This will follow all through all of their lives. That night, the night of that banquet, set the lives of all of those in attendance, on the same old path we have seen in this country! Men prevail and women are the subservient chattel!

Anonymous

This school district is out of touch with the norms of behavior of the 21st century in its approval of the humiliating awards given to young women on the cheerleading team. The implicit hatred of women and their bodies show a complete disregard for the law and no one, not even this school district, is above the law.

Eugenia

Body shaming is something every teacher should address it when they witness kids doing this to one another. It happens in cheerleading but also in dance classes, locker rooms and hallways. As for victim blaming, not only is that cruel but young women do need to learn protective skills; frat boys have a higher rate of sexual misconduct than other students and such information can help freshmen pick safer parties. It’s not victim blaming to teach caution and self defense.

Joseph Kucak MS...

As a former Student Services Administrator for KUSD, a Kenosha resident and the father of a wonderful daughter, I am "flabbergasted" and angry by the District's continuing decision to maintain this pattern of harassment. Shame on KUSD.

Amy S.

Students in grade school through college should never ever..... be verbally attacked or made the subject of vicious misogynistic jokes
especially when their event was supposed to be an awards where people are rewarded.
The school officials who permitted such hateful behavior against their own students should be fired!
School officials behavior should make every day at their school an environment that lifts up and rewards the students for what they have accomplished for positive behavior. Their jobs are to guide the students through their experiences at the school so that they will grow up to be happy and positive individuals that go on and make this world a kinder place and not one filled with cruelty.
These school officials failed miserably at their jobs and they should all be fired .
The school officials obviously do not follow any religious teachings and should be building good character in their students which should be their main goal. Instead, they still choose to continue with destructive behavior that negatively impacts their students.
In an atmosphere in so many schools that students are so underbpressure to achieve high grades and in addition be part of extracurricular activities so that they can go on to a college or university of their choice in the future. Suicide is ubiquitous in so many states in young students and school officials should be very watchful and caring that their students have genuine support from their school officials to make it through the very competitive environment that it takes to go on for a higher education .
The school officials need to be sent to psychological counseling and group therapy groups to learn how to interact with their students and hopefully they will learn something about themselves because their derogatory behavior towards their students is despicable.
Prayers for the students who need genuine caregiving from real school officials who do love to teach and do want to make their school system a stronger and more successful system.
FIRE THE INCOMPETENT INDIVIDUALS who perpetuate negativity against their own students!!!

Anonymous

I just cannot grasp that this kind of "stuff" is tolerated by any parent, enlightened students, the principal, the superintendent, etc. In my horror, I reasoned that the scholastic requirements at that school were poor, taught by the less talented teachers and "managed" by uninvolved parents. Next, I attempted to determine what the Tremper graduation rate was....not to be found. What an unbelievable shame!!!! GO, GO ACLU...please find a legal way to give these kids a fighting chance for a fulfilling life!!!

AnonymouS

The then candidate of the Republican Party for the 2016 election, showed direct evidence of his practice that the grabbing women was appreciated by them, and even offered to show how he could do so with the female reporter he was meeting for an interview by kissing and holding her. The person was elected President of the United States as the leader of the GOP. So you see, it's not hard to grasp how this "stuff" is tolerated by anyone. It's baked in. Approbation is given because, at least as I view it, to the general population billionaires have some type of moral immunity of conscience. I'm sure if you evaluated my actions in my youth, I learned that this is inculcated firmly in conservative philosophy -- I'M THE MAN.

Anonymous

The coach, AD and principal should all be fired!!!! Absolutely unacceptable!!!!!

Pages

Stay Informed