Statement of Alexandra Hay

April 6, 2004

ACLU "No-Fly" Lawsuit

No-Fly Lawsuit: Hay

Alexandra Hay
Age: 22
Nationality: U.S. Citizen
Occupation: Junior at Middlebury College in Vermont

As a college junior with a double major of French and English, I'm more interested in Proust and Trollope than government policies. I had never even heard of the No-Fly list until last November, when I was flying home from Vermont to spend Thanksgiving with my family. When I tried to check in at the airport, a ticket agent told me in front of everyone that my name was on a No-Fly list. I was embarrassed and also a little intimidated, especially because she couldn't tell me why I was on this list. I was even told that they were not allowed to tell me how to have my name removed. I had to wait a long time until she could finally let me on the plane.

Make a Difference

Your support helps the ACLU stand up for human rights and defend civil liberties.

Give Now

It happened again five days later on my way back to school, and this time I was even more worried because I was planning to fly to Paris in January 2004 for a semester abroad. That's when my Dad contacted the ACLU of Pennsylvania. The ACLU got in touch with the TSA and threatened to file a lawsuit if they couldn't get some kind of assurance that I would not be stopped again. I guess that got their attention - a TSA attorney escorted me through the Philadelphia Airport to make sure that I got on my flight to Paris without a problem. He also gave me a letter verifying my identity. But the letter said the TSA could not promise that there would be no delays or that I wouldn't be stopped in the future.

After they cleared me to fly, the ACLU withdrew the lawsuit, but I am participating in today's nationwide lawsuit because I don't think I should have to get a team of lawyers involved every time I want to get on a plane.

To this day, I still don't know why I was put on the list to begin with. I've heard it may be because my name matches someone else's name on the list, but I can't even get confirmation about that. It's all very secretive. But if the government is treating someone like me as a potential terrorist, I have to wonder - who is looking out for the real terrorists?
Statistics image