DeRay Mckesson, ACLU Urge Supreme Court to Defend Fundamental First Amendment Right to Protest
Prominent civil rights activist asks court to reverse a Fifth Circuit ruling that vitiates First Amendment protections for millions of protesters
WASHINGTON — The American Civil Liberties Union today asked the U.S. Supreme Court to review a lower court ruling that, if left standing, would gut First Amendment protections for the right to protest in the Fifth Circuit and potentially nationwide. The petition for certiorari was filed on behalf of DeRay Mckesson, a prominent civil rights activist and Black Lives Matter movement organizer.
The case stems from a 2016 protest to celebrate the life of Alton Sterling, a Black Baton Rouge, Louisiana, resident who was shot and killed by two on-duty police officers. The plaintiff, a former police officer, was hit by a rock at the protest and argues that Mckesson, who was also present but did not throw the rock, should be liable for the injury. In 2024, a lower court granted summary judgment to Mckesson and found that the plaintiff failed to produce enough evidence to establish that Mckesson planned or controlled the protest or caused the officer’s injuries — and held that, regardless, opening him to liability without any evidence that he even intended the rock throwing would violate the First Amendment. In March 2026, the Fifth Circuit reversed that ruling.
“This lawsuit is designed to prevent people from standing together to fight for their rights. Unless the Supreme Court steps in, anyone could be sued for what someone else does at a protest, even something they never intended or wanted to happen,” said DeRay Mckesson. “The threat of an expensive lawsuit could scare people away from protesting at all.”
Since 2016, this case has been at the Fifth Circuit, the Louisiana Supreme Court, and the U.S. Supreme Court. Mckesson is asking the Supreme Court to resolve the question of whether the theory at its center — that protest organizers can be liable for the unlawful acts of a third party at a protest not because they intended the illegality but because they “negligently organized” the protest such that the illegality was foreseeable — violates the First Amendment.
“The right to protest is fundamental to American democracy,” said Vera Eidelman, senior staff attorney with the ACLU’s Speech, Privacy, and Technology Project. “But, if the Supreme Court doesn’t intervene, the First Amendment’s protection may lose much of its force. No one will be able to protest without having to fear the possibility of paying for someone else’s bad behavior that they couldn’t control and didn’t intend. That’s the definition of chilling.”
After the Fifth Circuit accepted the theory in 2023, the Supreme Court declined to again hear Ford v. Mckesson in April 2024. Despite the court’s denial of the cert petition, Justice Sonia Sotomayor wrote a statement emphasizing the court’s 2023 decision in Counterman v. Colorado, which held that negligence is not the proper standard even when it comes to private threats, and that intent is necessary for political protest to be punished, should govern “any future proceedings in this case.”
“I am proud to represent DeRay Mckesson in this long fight and join him in urging the Supreme Court to overturn this profoundly mistaken decision,” said David T. Goldberg of Donahue, Goldberg, Herzog & Davidson. “The constitutional principles the Fifth Circuit discarded are fundamental, and the right at stake—to join with others to publicly demand accountability and justice—is a cornerstone of American self-government.”
After SCOTUS declined to review the case in 2024, it returned to district court, where Mckesson won summary judgment. Mckesson argued that the theory continues to violate the First Amendment and that, even if it is viable, Ford failed to meet his burden of proving the facts at the center of the case. The district court agreed. In March, the Fifth Circuit reversed that decision and opened the door for a jury trial of Mckesson to take place.
“It should shock every one of us that such a blatant attack on the First Amendment has made it this far in our courts,” said Alanah Odoms, executive director of the ACLU of Louisiana. “For 10 years, DeRay Mckesson has been made to answer for an act of violence someone else committed, simply because he attended a protest. If this nation truly reveres the Constitution as it claims to, this assault must fail. Once again, we are watching an attempt to force a retreat from rights guaranteed to every one of us.”
Mckesson is represented by David T. Goldberg of Donahue, Goldberg, Herzog & Davidson; David Cole; the American Civil Liberties Union; and the American Civil Liberties Union of Louisiana.
Ford v. Mckesson is a part of the ACLU’s Joan and Irwin Jacobs Supreme Court Docket. You can read the petition for certiorari here and more about the case here.