Government Cannot Shirk Accountability for Illegal Surveillance by Claiming State Secrets, ACLU Tells Chicago Judge

Affiliate: ACLU of Illinois
July 13, 2006 12:00 am

ACLU Affiliate
ACLU of Illinois
Media Contact
125 Broad Street
18th Floor
New York, NY 10004
United States


CHICAGO — In a rare oral argument, the American Civil Liberties Union of Illinois today asked a federal court judge in Chicago to block the government’s effort to shield telephone giant AT&T from accountability for sharing the telephone records of subscribers with the National Security Agency without lawful authorization. The ACLU alleges that AT&T violated the Electronic Communications Privacy Act of 1986 (EPCA) by providing the government with records of customers across Illinois.

In an extraordinary move, the United States Department of Justice intervened in the case, urging the case be dismissed. The government asserts that if AT&T reveals any information whatsoever about turning telephone records over to the government – even information already detailed by numerous media outlets – it will reveal “state secrets.”

“The court needs to take control of this case to ensure that fair procedures are afforded to our clients,” Harvey Grossman, ACLU of Illinois Legal Director told the court today.

The argument before U.S. District Court Judge Matthew Kennelly marks the third time in recent weeks that the government has argued the state secrets privilege assertion to urge a case be dismissed.
Recently, the Justice Department made the argument in a case brought by the Electronic Frontier Foundation in San Francisco challenging a similar AT&T program of turning over both telephone records and the content of calls to the government. On Monday, July 16, the government made the same argument in Detroit in the ACLU’s challenge to the NSA’s surveillance of domestic telephone calls without a warrant.

Grossman said that the government’s invocation of the state secrets privilege was an attempt to “immunize” government activity in the open-ended war on terror from scrutiny by independent judicial officers. Grossman asked Judge Kennelly to allow the case to move forward in a “step-by-step” fashion that protects intelligence gathering.

History has shown that the state secrets privilege has been used illegitimately to cover up wrongdoing. In a 1953 case, United States v. Reynolds, the government had claimed that disclosing a military flight accident report would jeopardize secret military equipment and harm national security. Nearly a half-century later, the truth came out: the accident report contained no state secrets, but instead confirmed that the cause of the crash was faulty maintenance of the B-29 fleet.

The case argued today was Terkel v. AT&T. Celebrated Chicago author Studs Terkel and prominent leaders in the medical, legal, political and faith communities filed the lawsuit in May charging that AT&T violated their privacy by secretly sharing the telephone records of millions of Americans with the government. The secret program was revealed in a May 11, 2006 article in USA Today. In addition to Terkel, the other plaintiffs in the case include: Barbara Flynn Currie, Majority Leader of the Illinois House of Representatives; Rabbi Gary Gerson of Oak Park Temple; Professor Diane Geraghty, Director of the Civitas ChildLaw Center at Loyola University School of Law, Chicago; James Montgomery, former Corporation Counsel for the City of Chicago; and Dr. Quinten Young, a physician and advocate for health care reform.

“There is no ‘secret’ at risk in this case. Terrorists know that phone conversations and records are monitored. We hope the court will allow our clients to determine if AT&T is complying with the law,” added Grossman.

Assisting the ACLU of Illinois in the case are Chicago attorneys Marc Beem, Daniel Feeney and Zachary Freeman of Miller, Shakman & Beem; F. Thomas Hecht, James M. Carlson and Michael Philippi of Ungarett & Harris; and William Hooks of Hooks Law Offices.

For more information on this case, as well as the ACLU lawsuit filed in Michigan, go to

Every month, you'll receive regular roundups of the most important civil rights and civil liberties developments. Remember: a well-informed citizenry is the best defense against tyranny.

Learn More About the Issues in This Press Release