Congress Is Pushing Vouchers in the Tax Bill. That Won't Help Students With Disabilities

As the Senate worked through the night last Friday on massive legislation that would overhaul the U.S. tax code, Republican Sen. Ted Cruz of Texas added an amendment that would effectively transform a college savings account into a school voucher for K-12 education. If the amendment survives, it would advance a type of policy that hurts the public school system and, as new evidence illustrates, hurts students with disabilities.

The provision would expand 529 savings accounts, which offer tax benefits for saving for future college costs, to cover tuition and other expenses at elementary and secondary schools, including private and religious schools. Given that 80 percent of private schools in America are sectarian, incentivizing families to enroll their children in private schools means incentivizing them to enroll — or continue to enroll —their children in private religious schools. Additionally, the type of tax break proposed in this bill would increasingly exacerbate educational disparities by reducing available funding and resources for public schools. It would leave those remaining in public schools to be educated in an underfunded system of last resort. Public schools, which serve 90 percent of the country’s students, are obligated to serve all students equally. But the same cannot be said for private schools, which can, for instance, reject students because they have disabilities. Numerous studies already present plenty of evidence of the ways that vouchers do not advance educational equity.

And last week, the U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) presented more in a new report that studied 27 voucher programs across the country. The watchdog found that vouchers fail to provide necessary or accurate information to parents of students with disabilities about the rights students forfeit when enrolling in a private voucher school. A third of the programs do not provide any information about these changes in rights under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA). And the vast majority — 83 percent — of students who enrolled in a voucher program for students with disabilities did so through a program that provided either no information or inaccurate information about changes in rights.

Making matters worse, neither IDEA nor Department of Education regulations require that parents be informed about changes in their child’s rights. When they do learn that their children don’t have the same protections, parents can be blindsided. According to the GAO, “confusion arises because parents are under the impression that since school choice programs are operated and funded by the state, and are often designed for students with disabilities, their children will have similar protections to those ensured to public school children under IDEA.”

This means that parents may unknowingly send their children to schools that aren’t required to have certified special education teachers, that do not provide some or all special education and related services, that do not educate students with disabilities with nondisabled peers to the maximum extent possible, and that do not adhere to disciplinary guidelines. With no requirement to uphold these rights, or even to provide accurate information about the forfeiture of these rights, you end up with scenarios like this:

“One family told us they were surprised to learn that teachers providing special education services to their child were not trained to provide those services, and another parent described changing schools because they learned aspects of their child’s disability could not be accommodated only after enrolling their child in a school.”

The weaknesses in these voucher programs put students of color with disabilities especially at risk. As detailed in a coalition letter today to Secretary of Education Betsy DeVos, these students are disproportionately subjected to punitive discipline practices, placed in restrictive learning environments, and misidentified for certain categories of special education. They are more vulnerable to a lack of clarity about rights and loss of IDEA protections.

It isn’t news that private school voucher programs overall have major accountability problems, and not only for students with disabilities. The GAO itself has twice studied the District of Columbia’s voucher program and found similar weaknesses in administration, oversight, and provision of information.

Despite all this evidence, the Senate amendment was adopted last week — by a 51-50 vote after Vice President Mike Pence broke a tie — and the House bill included a mostly similar provision in its own tax legislation, which has been praised by voucher proponent DeVos. Members from both houses of Congress are now attempting to reconcile the differences between the bills in a conference committee. This means that Congress is poised to use the tax code to advance the religious education of certain students at the expense of public schools and the students who attend them — even while evidence continues to mount regarding the harmful effects of vouchers, particularly for students with disabilities.

If Congress really wants to help every individual child, it should focus on ways to improve public schools — particularly those that serve underprivileged students, families, and communities— rather than chip away at their ability to serve all students. The government should not incentivize families to choose religious education through tax policy.

View comments (13)
Read the Terms of Use

Lewis Control

Is it possible that the public school system can be hurt anymore than it already is?

Dr. Joseph Goebbels

I like that Governor Abbott from Texas. He’s in a chair by choice. Yup choice, dumb ass broke his back on skis.

Elon Throatpoker

Why can’t human beings separate religions from god? When will they understand that “god” the creator of all that exist is not dependent upon our beliefs or religion?

God laughs at all the oaths, pledges of allegiance, and other mantras humans perpetrat in the name of God.

God is laughing at you all. She got drunk and flushed the toilet

Al Franken

I like to grope women. But only white women. They are the most beautiful. I don't like gay women. They are nasty. Besides they aren't as easy to fondle.

Dr. Joseph Goebbels

I like to select the women from races I fear and perform sterilization experiences. experiences, not experiments because white Caucasians love being masochist

George Klaes

When is the ACLU going to start defending the rights of parents and children and stop marching to the tune of the teachers' union and the anti-Catholic bigots?


funny I begged the SC ACLU to help kids with disabilities in SC after sending proof of systemic violations acknowledge by the state... they said they couldnt be bothered to worry about my personal issues.

Kathryn Young

As a parent of a dyslexic student I can say public schools are failing our dyslexic students and all parents should have the right to and be able to afford to send their children to schools that have teachers trained in research based methods that have been proven to be successful for teach dyslexic students.


So true!

Shantel Kelly

i am so happy to share this testimony with the world because generally there are so many doubts about the cure of hpv and cancer This is real take it serious, i am so happy that today i can give this testimony to the world and also help in saving life of people who has been condemned for death just as i was ,who will believe that herbs can cure hpv and cancer completely from the body, i never believe that this will work, i have spend a lot of money getting drugs from the hospital to keep me healthy, it got to a time that all i was waiting for is death to come because i was broke and i already have strong outbreaks from the hpv, one day i was going through the internet asking questions online just to know more about the latest development in the medical sector to see if there is still hope then i stumbled on a post about about this great man called Dr. Ehiagwina through a publicly made a testimony on how she was also cured of ALS by this herbal doctor who is well known for his strong ancient herbal practice at first i doubted both the woman and the doctor just as so many that see's this post would doubt because medically it has been proven impossible but later i decided to give him a try so i emailed him I did not believe him that much, I just wanted to give him a try, he replied my mail and Needed some Information about me, then I sent them to him, he prepare herbal medicine and sent it through Courier Service for delivery, he gave my details to the Courier Office. they told me that 3-5 days I will receive the package and after receiving it, i took the medicine as prescribed by him at the end of 13days that the medicine lasted, he told me to go to the hospital for a test, and i went, surprisingly after the test the doctor confirm me hpv negative and cancer disappear i thought it was a joke, i went to other hospitals and was also negative the doctors were speechless and i said it was a miracle, thank you sir for saving my life even if you cannot see this post i shall never stop testifying the impact you made in my life by restoring back my life when i was being stigmatized and even avoided by family and friends , I promise I will always testify of your good works. Dr. Ehiagwina contact: OR call +2348162084504 you can also add him on whatsapp.


Stay Informed