1776 Project Foundation & U.S. v. Carvalho, et al.

Last Update: November 13, 2026

What's at Stake

We are continuing our multi-generational fight for equality and opportunity for Black and Latino students in the country’s second largest school district. The American Civil Liberties Union and the ACLU of Southern California (together, ACLU) – along with our co-counsel Willkie Farr & Gallagher LLP – intervened in a federal court case, 1776 Project Found. & U.S. v. Carvalho, et al., to protect the interests of Black and Latino students in the Los Angeles Unified School District (LAUSD). Plaintiff 1776 Project Foundation (Plaintiff 1776) and Plaintiff-Intervenor United States of America (DOJ) filed a federal lawsuit against LAUSD in January 2026. DOJ and Plaintiff 1776 are challenging part of a court-ordered desegregation remedy. They are opposing LAUSD’s designation of certain schools serving majority students of color – schools known as Predominantly Hispanic, Black, Asian, or Other non-Anglo (PHBAO) – for support services and additional points in the magnet school admissions process (PHBAO Program).

The PHBAO Program is a component of LAUSD’s longstanding desegregation remedies, which were ordered by the Los Angeles Superior Court in 1981 in Crawford v. Board of Education. The ACLU secured the desegregation order after fighting LAUSD in state court for almost 20 years to dismantle its segregated school system. DOJ and Plaintiff 1776 seek to halt the PHBAO Program, standing in opposition to equity measures designed to promote desegregation and alleviate the harmful effects of unlawful racial isolation in the District’s schools.

Summary


In 1963, the ACLU filed a class action lawsuit against LAUSD to challenge its segregated school system on behalf of all Black and Latino students attending school in the District. After a lengthy trial, the Los Angeles Superior Court found in 1970 that LAUSD’s schools were substantially segregated and ordered the District to take “reasonable and feasible” steps to desegregate.

The segregation was severe and extensive. A federal survey of public school enrollment found that LAUSD was one of the most segregated school systems in the entire country. For example, in 1968, eighty elementary schools had Black student enrollments that exceeded 50%, even though Black students comprised only 22.6% of LAUSD’s total student population. Additionally, out of the eighty majority-Black elementary schools, seventy-two of the schools were more than 90% Black. In that same year, the District enrolled majority Black student populations in fifteen junior high schools and nine high schools. But out of these schools, thirteen junior high schools and seven high schools had Black student enrollments that surpassed 90%.

After the conclusion of the trial and the Crawford court’s decision on the District’s liability in 1970, the ACLU and LAUSD litigated the desegregation remedies that would be used to address segregation and alleviate the harmful effects of unlawful racial isolation. The PHBAO Program is a key component of the desegregation remedies the Crawford court ultimately ordered LAUSD to implement in 1981, and the Crawford court’s 1981 desegregation order remains in effect today.

On June 5, 2026, ACLU filed a Motion to Intervene in DOJ and Plaintiff 1776’s federal lawsuit to protect the interests of Black and Latino LAUSD students who are the plaintiff class in Crawford. The federal court granted the ACLU’s intervention motion on August 11, 2026. The court held that the motion was timely filed, raised common questions on the legality of the PHBAO Program, and did not prejudice the original parties.

On June 22, 2026, the ACLU and LAUSD filed separate motions to dismiss DOJ and Plaintiff 1776’s lawsuit. The parties have fully briefed the motions to dismiss and are awaiting a decision from the court.

News & Commentary


Support our on-going litigation and work in the courts Donate now

Related Issues