Back to News & Commentary

On the Podcast: Defending Speech We Hate

A man uses a bullhorn as he demonstrates with supporters of Donald Trump outside the Pennsylvania Convention Center 
On At Liberty, we unpack the truth behind accusations that the ACLU has abandoned its commitment to the First Amendment.
A man uses a bullhorn as he demonstrates with supporters of Donald Trump outside the Pennsylvania Convention Center 
June 22, 2021
Ines Santos, she/her/hers, Communications Intern, ACLU

The ACLU’s role in defending freedom of speech has been hotly contested by some critics recently — but these conversations are far from new. Throughout its history, the organization has had to balance its dedication to advancing civil rights for marginalized people and protecting First Amendment rights for those with whom it disagrees. This adherence to civil liberties is not always popular, as evidenced by the 30,000 members that left following the controversial time in the 1970s when the ACLU defended the rights of neo-nazis to march in Skokie, Illinois.


Watch Now:

Video thumbnail reads "Defending Speech We Hate" with photo of former host Emerson Skyes and former ACLU director Aryeh Neier
This embed will serve content from {{ domain }}. See our privacy statement

On the other hand, contemporary critics accuse the organization of having abandoned its defense of free speech, opting instead to solely support liberal causes. So has the ACLU lost its way? A closer look at the history of free speech legislation — and the ACLU’s role in defending it — shatters the false dichotomy between the First Amendment and civil rights. While successfully upholding the right to speak freely sometimes means defending bigots, the biggest benefactors of free speech rights tend to be the most vulnerable populations.

In this week’s episode of At Liberty, ACLU attorney and former host Emerson Sykes is joined by former ACLU Executive Director Aryeh Neier, who oversaw the organization during the Skokie trials. The two discuss European hate speech laws, the organization’s reputation over the years, and why the present-day is not the lowest point for free speech in the US.

Listen to this episode
This embed will serve content from soundcloud.com. See our privacy statement