Rampant Abuses in Immigration Detention Prove ICE Is Rotten to the Core

Last Friday, a Honduran asylum seeker suffered an unthinkable tragedy when she had a stillbirth while in ICE detention in Texas. While the facts of this case are still coming to light, it is only one of many tragic incidents involving immigrants detained by the federal government in recent months.

According to reports, the 24-year-old woman who was six months pregnant had spent days detained in Border Patrol custody before being transferred to the Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) Port Isabel Detention Center in South Texas. From there, she was taken to a hospital where she suffered this terrible trauma.  

And hers is far from an isolated incident.

Since fall 2017, we and our partners have been tracking the treatment of pregnant women in ICE detention following a policy change by the Trump administration that eliminated the presumption of release for pregnant women and removed internal reporting requirements. ICE does not publicly report this information, but recent statements to the media note that 1,655 pregnant women were booked into ICE custody over a 10-month period between 2017-2018 and that 28 women may have miscarried in ICE custody over the past two years. 

These and so many other cases point to one conclusion: Immigration detention poses life-threatening health and safety risks for the tens of thousands of people who are locked up across the country.

Just this month, we learned that ICE was force-feeding nine Indian men detained in El Paso, Texas, where they were protesting their prolonged detention and conditions at the facility where they are detained. These asylum seekers became so desperate they put their own bodies on the line to shed light on their mistreatment. This is only one of many such hunger strikes in immigration detention over several years.  

These abuses are not only a problem with ICE. The Border Patrol operates a system of jails where migrants are detained, typically in the nation’s border regions. These jails are notoriously known as “hieleras,” or iceboxes, because of the frigid temperatures inside of the cells. The conditions in these cells are so unsafe that a lawsuit was filed in 2015 to force the agency to meet basic constitutional standards.

In just the past three months, there have been at least three deaths in Border Patrol jails, including the tragic deaths of 8-year-old Felipe Gomez Alonzo and 7-year-old Jakelin Caal. The deaths of these two children prompted the agency for the first time to issue a directive requiring public notification of in-custody deaths, and the commissioner for Customs and Border Protection acknowledged that these cells are no place for children.      

Even recent reports by the DHS Office of Inspector General document deplorable conditions and continuing serious problems with medical care in ICE detention facilities. Additionally, the OIG has issued reports uncovering gross abuses in the contracting and inspections systems that are critically important for public and congressional oversight. These reports provide a framework for understanding the depth of dysfunction within ICE over its detention operations. 

ICE repeatedly contends that its own inspections ensure adequate oversight and protect the safety and well-being of people in its custody. Based on these reports, and the countless incidents of death, abuse, and mistreatment of those in immigration detention, we know nothing could be further from the truth.

Despite these claims, the administration’s intent is clear: strip away the humanity and dignity of immigrants through hostile, anti-immigrant policies, like family separation and zero tolerance. Then lockup as many people as possible in immigration detention without access to counsel or family and community support and in such harsh conditions that they will simply abandon their legal claims. 

The scope of this crisis can and should be measured in human terms.

During negotiations over the federal government shutdown, we learned that ICE was detaining over 48,000 people, well over the number permitted under its appropriated funding. We also know that DHS was raiding other federal accounts like FEMA to cover the costs of detaining more immigrants. Given what we know, this unchecked spending and expansion must end.  

Abuses in detention are often chalked up to “one bad apple.” Recent cases of abuse; scathing reports about conditions, contracting, and inspections in immigration detention; and the blatant overspending of taxpayer dollars reveal pervasive problems and tell a different story. ICE is rotten to the core.

View comments (47)
Read the Terms of Use

Anonymous

Why the does the Aclu care about a still birth and when they support the wholesale slaughter of innocent babies i.e. infanticide and abortion

Anonymous

Read the FACTS about abortion, not the so-called information often seen.

Anonymous

MAGA! THROW ALL THE ILLEGALS BACK ACROSS THE BORDER! THEY DON'T BELONG HERE, TAKE ALL THE,BLEEDING HEARTS WITH THEM. TRUMP 2020!!

Anonymous

Thank you for your deplorable opinion!

Anonymous

LOVE YOUR COMMENT: they are bringing all kinds of illness to America and our citizens will suffer because of them.

Concerned

There may be serious issues in ICE and border security detention. But your pregnancy statistics are not useful data to prove that. The average rate of miscarriage is 20%. Of the 1,655 women booked, 20% would be 333, far more than the 28 you mention.

In general, we need better accountability and clarity on the details of detention - food, medical treatment, possible abuse of the detainees. And clearer guidelines on issues like force feeding and punishments.

Anonymous

Nope, these illegal aliens must be immediately returned to their home countries. They are economic migrants, not legitimate refugee or asylum seekers. The cost to the American taxpayer is well over $135 BILLION. ENOUGH IS ENOUGH. We have our own needs for American Citizens. Where is the ACLU fighting on behalf of them?

Anonymous

I am sorry about the baby but don’t put the blame on ICE there are different reasons why the baby didn’t make it. I as American taxpayers am tried of taking care of them. DEPORTED DEPORTED PUT E-VERIFIED IN PLACE and start changing these people for room and board. DEPORTED all of them. Start giving birth control to the women and condemn to the men. Have sex education for them in countries.

Anonymous

ICE is becoming the gestapo of the Trump administration. They've started arresting U.S. citizens "by mistake."

Anonymous

ICE IS the gestapo of the Trump administration.

Pages

Stay Informed